OK, as we are now into July, its high time I did another post and this will be yet another revisitation of a Doctor Who story (which was also a revisit!). And the story is hailed as one of the all time classics of the original show which is The Talons of Weng-Chiang from the Tom Baker era.
So, I will add a few bits and bobs to the sections to expand on them a little although they are quite well expanded as it is.
So, with that said, let's take another look at this story and see if it still is a classic.
STORY
So, the story begins with the
TARDIS landing in London back in the Victorian times, as the Doctor and
Leela (Louise Jameson) emerge wearing Victorian clothes. The Doctor and
Leela while they look around the local area, they hear a scream and
they find a group of Chinese coolies who are attacking a cab driver.
The Doctor and Leela fight them off, as they hear the sound of a police
whistle they flee, and the Doctor trips up one of them, just in time for
a Sergeant (David McKail) to find them and he asks them to come to the
station.
Meanwhile at the Palace theatre, a famous Chinese magician, Li
H'sen Chang (John Bennett) is performing an extended run at the
theatre, much to the delight of the owner, Henry Gordon Jago
(Christopher Benjamin). Chang however was accosted by the cab driver
earlier on and he accused him of putting his wife into some weird
trance and since then she has disappeared. After this Chang is called
to the police station where he is asked to be an interpreter for the
coolie, the Doctor and Leela caught. Chang unbeknownst to the Doctor and
Leela discretely gives the coolie a scorpion venom pill, which kills
the coolie instantly. Chang denies that he did anything and wishes them
good night, but on examining the dead coolie's hand, the Doctor sees a
tatoo of the Tong of the Black Scorpion, who were a dangerous political
organisation who worshipped the ancient god, Weng-Chiang.
The
Doctor and Leela then head to the mortuary where they find where they
speak to Professot Litefoot (Trevor Litefoot) who is examining the
bodies and tells the Doctor that the cab driver, was a man named Joseph
Buller, who was the husband of one of the missing girls, Emma Buller that went missing in mysterious circumstances. The
Doctor finds rat hairs on Buller's body, which suggests to him that he
was killed by a large rat, and that the god Weng Chaing, was the master
of abundance who could make things grow. On this hunch, the Doctor
checks the sewers with Leela and they find a large rat, which advances
on them, but they manage to escape just in time.
In the
meantime we find out that Chang is actually a servant of the so called
God, Weng-Chiang, who is in fact a war criminal from the 51st Century,
Magnus Greel (Michael Spice) who is stranded in this time, and he is desperately looking for the time cabinet he travelled in. However as a
result of having used the time cabinet, which is based on an unstable
form called Zygma energy, Greel is left hideously deformed and has to
wear mask to hide his true features.
It also is revealed that the girls
who disappeared have in fact been captured by Chang and taken to Greel,
who uses a distillation chamber to drain their life energies into his
own body, in order to revitilise himself, as he dying from the effects
of his time travel. Chang also in his task of trying to find the time
cabinet is aided by a the small waxwork doll, Mr Sin (Roy Deep) which is
in fact a homunculus (small robotic human) who came from the future
with Greel.
And as things progress the Doctor and Leela
eventually cross paths with Greel, as well as meeting up with Jago and
Litefoot, who all pull their resources together to try and defeat the
evil villain from the future, who if he finds the time cabinet again, it
could have disastrous consequences for them all...
THOUGHTS
The Talons
of Weng-Chiang is without a doubt one of the real highlights of the Tom
Baker era, the
scripts, sets and performances are all excellent. Robert Holmes, who
was the script editor during the Philip Hinchcliffe tenure, and also
wrote the story, has crafted a terrific adventure, which is creepy,
menacing as well as very entertaining.
The story also succeeds in
bringing together another partnership, with Henry Gordon Jago and
Professor Litefoot, who in the story make an unlikely duo, but they ultimately help each other and the Doctor in their fight against Greel.
In fact in a way it seems like there is a peculiar trio here, a la
Sherlock Homes style (which this story pays more than a close homage to)
with the Doctor being Sherlock Holmes and Professor Litefoot being John
Watson. As for the gothic themes that were seen to be running now and
then through
the Hinchcliffe era, they really come to the fore here, and in this
story
Holmes and Hinchcliffe find the perfect balance of drama and fun and it was a great swansong for their tenure on the show.
PERFORMANCES (Warning: this section may contain spoilers!)
In
terms of the performances there is much to enjoy here as the cast are all on top form.
Starting Tom Baker who is great once again as the Fourth Doctor, and he provides his usual
commanding, enigmatic and humorous qualities.
And Tom has his share of good scenes such as the one where Doctor goes
to the police station not long after he and Leela are attacked by some
coolies. So, the Doctor in the scene is asked by Sergeant Kyle at the
station some questions and he asks the Doctor if and Leela have an
address, so the Doctor tells him "No, sergeant, we're travellers". So,
Kyle says "I see. Persons of no fixed abode" and the Doctor corrects him
"No, no. We have an abode but its not fixed!" and Kyle says to the
Doctor "I can give you and the girl a fixed abode quite easily, sir" and
the Doctor says under his breath "Flat-footed imbecile!" and Kyle asks
"What was that, sir?" and the Doctor irritably says "It was nothing
complimentary, get on with it, Sergeant!".
So, as Kyle says they have their hands full with all the missing persons inquiries, the Doctor impatiently tells him "Sergeant, that is all
irrelevant. I have come here to lay evidence!". Kyle however says "We'll
come to that in good time, sir" and the Doctor shouts " We'll come to
that now, Sergeant. We've just prevented a kidnapping, a robbery or even
a murder. My friend here caught one of the attackers. Let's come to it
now, shall we?!".
Then there is the scene where Chang arrives at the police station where
Kyle asks him to question the Chinese coolie. However, Chang in the
scene quietly slips a poison pill to the coolie, who takes it and as the
Doctor finally works out who Chang is, he announces "Got it! Li H'sen
Chang! The master of magic mesmerism! Show us a trick!" and suddenly the
coolie gives a cry and collapses dead over the table. So, the Doctor
examines the coolie and says "Scorpion venom!" and Kyle asks "Scorpion
venom?" and the Doctor says "Highly concentrated scorpion venom. It
killed him almost instantly".
So, Chang then denies any knowledge of what just happened and leaves the
station and the Doctor having examined the coolie and identified a
tattoo belonging to a criminal group known as the Tong of the black
scorpion, he says to Kyle "If the tong of
the Black scorpion is here in London you're going to need all the help
you can get, now cut along and do what I say now!". And the Doctor's authority is so strong, Kyle is compelled to obey him and says "Yes, sir" and he walks off.
And there is the moment where the Doctor chases Greel around
the Palace theatre late at night and he finds Jago later on the floor
unconscious and brings him round. So, as Greel escapes, the Doctor tends to Jago, who asks
"Shouldn't we go to the police?" and the Doctor says "Oh, Henry Gordon
Jago, then our reclusive phantom would simply vanish. Poof!" and as
Jago asks him what he will do the Doctor replies "Think. Then have some
supper!".
And there is also
the scene where the Doctor traverses the Thames in a small boat as he
holds an old rifle in his hands and he says to Litefoot, who is with him
"My dear Litefoot, I've got a lantern, a pair of waders, and possibly
the most feared piece of hand artillery in all of England! What could
possibly go wrong??". And as Litefoot says "Well that for a start, it
hasn't been used for 50 years, if you try and use it, it might explode
in your face!" and the Doctor replies "Explode?? Unthinkable! It was
made in Birmingham!".
There is also another amusing scene when the
Doctor looks at Leela's transformation when she puts on a beautiful
Victorian era dress. So, the Doctor says to Leela "I'll be proud to take
you to the theatre lookign like that" and Leela excitedly asks "We're
going to the theatre?" and the Doctor with a grin says to her "I have
an appointment at the
Palace Theatre tonight, and if you are very good, I'll buy you an
orange".
Another great scene is where Greel turns up at Lightfoot's place to take the time
key for the cabinet from the Doctor. So in the scene, Greel grows tired
of the Doctor's flipancy and he shouts "The time key, Doctor!" and the
Doctor says "Oh the time key! Heavens to
Betsy! I'm always putting things down and wondering where I put them!".
So, Greel warns the Doctor "I will give you three seconds to produce
the time key or I will kill the girl...one...two...three...kill her!"
but then the Doctor suddenly produces the key and Greel shouts "Stop!".
So, as Greel urgently shouts "Give it to me!" the Doctor jumps back and
says "Careful! I might have dropped it!" and Greel says to the Doctor of
Leela "Give me that key and I'll spare her life!" and the Doctor tells
him "Never trust a man with dirty fingernails!".
So, the Doctor insists that he will only give Greel the key if he takes
him to the House of the Dragon and he releases Jago and Litefoot. So,
the Doctor tells Greel "Tell you what, I'll give you the trionic lattice
when we get to the House of the Dragon" and Greel asks him "What
trickery is this?!" and the Doctor says "No trickery. You're holding two
of my friends there. I want them released". Greel then asks "Two
blundering dolts?! Why?!" and the Doctor tells him "I doubt you could
understand that but that's the condition" so Greel agrees to. So, before
they go, Greel tells them to bring the girl but the Doctor says "No!
The girl stays" and Greel warns the Doctor "You would be wise not to
press me too far!" and the Doctor commandingly says to him "Just lead
on".
WARNING BIG SPOILER COMING UP IN THIS PARAGRAPH!
And last of all is the scene where the Doctor and the others are caught
up in a fight with Greel at the House of the Dragon where Mr Sin has the
Doctor and his friends caught in the cross-hairs of a dragon laser gun.
So, the Doctor pleads with Greel not to use the time cabinet or there
will be disaster "Greel, listen, if you activate the Zigma beam, it will
be certain death for all of us!" and Greel weakly says "Lies, Doctor!".
However the Doctor continues to plead with Greel "Listen, Greel! GREEL,
LISTEN! The Zigma beam is at full stretch. If you trigger it again,
it'll mean certain collapse. You know what that means?!". Greel however
weakly says "You can't fool me!" and the Doctor shouts "There'll be a
huge implosion, Greel, and you'll be at the centre of it. The zigma
experiments were a disaster!"
So, after the Doctor finally defeats Greel by pushing him into the
distillation chamber, it disintegrates Greel's body. So, Jago asks "But
where was he from? Where did he go?" and the Doctor tells him "He was a
foe from the future, Henry". Then suddenly Mr Sin jumps down and attacks
Leela and then the Doctor, who wrestles with Sin and throws him to the
floor and he pulls out the chip that controls him and he takes the
trionic lattice and places it on the ground and says to the others "I'm
bringing the Zigma experiments to an end". So, the Doctor crushes the
lattice with his foot and then we hear a call in the distance of muffins
and the Doctor says to the other "Its the muffin man. Come on. I'll buy
you some muffins!".
Louise Jameson is also fine as
Leela, and yep she does look pretty fine in that Victorian dress
(although I miss her sexy leather skins!).
And Louise has quite a few highlights in the story that include the
scene where the Doctor and Leela are taken to the police station just
after the coolies attacked them. So, in the scene the Doctor tells Leela
to tell Sergeant Kyle what they saw and she tells Kyle "The man they
were carrying was dead. They stabbed him through the heart!". Kyle
however skeptically asks Leela "Really, Miss and how can you be sure of
that?" and Leela firmly tells Kyle "I am a warrior of the Sevateem. I
know the different sounds of death. Now put our prisoner to the
torture!".
There is also the scene where Leela is interested in
Litefoot's pathology examination of the cabbie who was killed and she
says "You say you can tell the height of the attacker by the way the
blade was thrust? But when aiming for the heart, we were always told to
strike under the breastbone!". Litefoot then looks stunned at Leela's
statement and the Doctor grins and tells him "Savage! Found floating
down the Amazon in a hotbox!".
She
also has an amusing scene where she eats with Litefoot at
his house, but rather than use a plate, she sticks a carving knife into
a cut
of meat and she weighs the knife in her hand and tells Litefoot "Its a good
knife!". So, as Leela starts eating it with her hands, Litefoot looks on
awkwardly and Leela asks "Aren't you going to eat?" and Litefoot smiles
a little and says "Yes, just going to eat" and he picks up a chicken
wing and starts to eat it aswell.
Jameson also has quite a few
impressive dramatic moments such as the one where Leela is tied and
placed in Greel's distillation chamber and she says "I will not plead,
but know this: when we are both in the great hereafter I will hunt you
down, BENT FACE and put you through my agony a THOUSAND TIMES!".
And clearly Leela struggles with the
customs and social etiquette of the Victorian era more than Eliza
Doolittle ever did! And this brings to mind the story's last scene
where Litefoot tries to train up Leela on the social etiquette during
tea and Litefoot says "I would say "one lump or two, Miss Leela". To
which you will reply "one will suffice, thank you". And Leela asks
"Suppose I want two" and Litefoot firmly says "Oh no, no, no, no. One
lump for ladies" and Leela says "Then why do you ask me?!".
Christopher Benjamin as Henry Gordon Jago, the pompous theatre owner,
who has a large vocabulary and likes to act big, but at the same time
he's a coward, who would flee at any sign of danger, but towards the end
he plays his part in fighting the baddies.
Benjamin naturally has some
great scenes in the story that include the one where Jago speaks to his stagehand,
Casey, and says to him "I will look over those lugubrious lineaments at
the crepuscular hour!" and Casey says "Eh???" to which Jago replies "See
you in the morning!".
Another good scene from Benjamin is when the
Doctor meets with Jago at the theatre and pretends to audition for him
and Jago is very unimpressed by the Doctor tricks "Auditions start on
Saturday morning, ten o'clock sharp!" and the Doctor continues to show
some more and Jago continues to be unimpressed and says "Is that all?"
and the Doctor says "No, dramatic recitations, tap dancing. I can play
the trumpet in a bowl of live goldfish!" and Jago wearily says "Don't
bother coming back on Saturday!".
Another good scene is when Jago first
pays a visit to Litefoot and he mistakes him to be Litefoot's butler
(as Litefoot is wearing an apron at the time) and Jago arrogantly says
to him "Kindly tell your master that Henry Gordon Jago wishes to see
him!" and Litefoot protests and Jago says "Confound your insolence, sir,
and announce yourself!" and Litefoot snaps back at him telling him he
is Litefoot and Jago changes tack quickly saying "Why dash me optics! I
should have realised. That brow, those hands. England's peerless
premier professor of pathology!" then he doffs his hat at him "Henry
Gordon Jago are your service!".
And lastly there is the scene where Litefoot and Jago are being held
captive by Greel and Jago admits that he isn't brave when it comes to
it. So, Jago admits "Well, I'm not so bally brave when it comes to it. I
try to be but I'm not..." and Litefoot says "Well when it comes to
it...I don't suppose anybody is" and Jago says "Well just thought I
would let you know, in case I let the side down" and Litefoot smiles and
reassures Jago "You won't, Henry. I know you won't".
Trevor Baxter is
also excellent Professor
Litefoot, as he plays Litefoot as a plucky character, who will stand up
for a fight, and his scenes with Christopher Benjamin are great, and
some of the highlights of the story.
Baxter also has some great scenes that include the one where Litefoot
get's ready to finish up his shift are his autopsy on the body of the
dead cab driver. So, Litefoot says to the Doctor "They were both
poisoned, of course. One orally, the other intravenously. I understand
you suggested scorpion venom?" and the Doctor says "Yes, in concentrated
form". Litefoot asks the Doctor "I'd like to hear more about that.
You're in this line, I take it?" and the Doctor tells him "I dabble a
bit. Dilettante" and Litefoot says "Surely more than that. I got a
zoologist colleague to look at our last cadaver. It seems he thinks it's
the work of a rat, too. What an amazing night it's been!" and Leela
says to him "Its not over yet".
So, Litefoot continues "It's been jolly interesting, wouldn't you say?
Most of the corpses around here are jolly dull. Now I've got a couple of
inscrutable Chinks and a poor perisher who was chewed by a giant rat,
having been stabbed by a midget!". The Doctor curious asks "A midget?"
and Litefoot says "Angle of the wound. Oh, upon my soul. I'm sure we
shouldn't be discussing such things in front of the fair sex. Forgive
us, ma'am!". So, Leela a bit puzzled asks the Doctor "Does he mean me?"
and the Doctor says "I don't think so".
Another scene is where the Doctor, Leela and Litefoot ride in a carriage
and Leela questions what Litefoot is doing as he smokes his pipe. So,
Leela asks "Why is there fire coming out of your mouth?" and Litefoot
out of surprise says "Pon
my soul, hasn't the girl ever seen a pipe before?" and the Doctor says
"There's no tobacco where Leela comes from" and Litefoot says "Sounds
healthy, but exceedingly dull!".
Another good scene is when Jago goes around to Litefoot's home but is
not aware of who he is and mistakes him as a servant and Jago says
"Confound your
insolence, sir, and just announce me!" and Litefoot says "Consider
yourself announced, sir! I'M Litefoot!". And in the scene
Litefoot decides that he and Jago should try and locate Weng-Chiang
themselves and he says to Jago "If you and I keep a discreet eye on the
theatre we might nab this fellow, should he return. We might be lucky,
Mr Jago. And if we are, I have a few lumps to repay!" (referencing the
fact he had been knocked out twice already!).
John Bennett is
also very good as
Li H'sen Chang, the enigmatic and mysterious magician, who obeys Greel
blindly at first, but realises altogether a bit too late that Greel
later deserts him. Bennett also has some excellent make-up to make look
like a gent from the Orient, which looks very convincing (despite the
fact he wouldn't be able to move his eyebrows!).
Bennet also has some
good scenes which include the scene where he arrives at the police
station to help the inspector with their enquiries and the Doctor asks
him "Don't I know you? Aren't you Chinese?" and Chang says "I
understand we all look the same!". So, after Chang discreetly passes the
coolie a poison pill, which the coolie takes and dies from, the Doctor
asks Chang "What did you do?" and Chang says "Nothing. What are you
suggesting?". The Doctor then examines a tattoo on the coolie's hand and
he says "The tong of the black scoprion. One of the most dangerous
politico-criminal organisations in the world. Wouldn't you agree, Li
S'hen Chang?". However, Chang pleads ignorance and says "You seem
remarkably well-informed, Doctor. Alas, I know nothing of these matters.
Most regrettable incident. Goodnight, Sergeant". And before Chang goes
he turns to Leela and says to her "I'm sure we shall meet again. Perhaps
under more pleasant circumstances".
Then there is the scene where Chang
uses his skill as a hypnotist (along with his heightened powers learned
from Greel) to hypnotise to a couple of female workers to come with him,
and one of them is substituted by Leela. And as Chang returns for them
he grabs them both and says "Come! I said come! You painted drabs!
My master must feed!".
Another good scene for Bennett also
comes when Chang performs his live act infront of a full house in the
theatre and he asks for an assistant to help him with a trick as the
Doctor comes on stage, he asks him to step into a cabinet, but the
Doctor is seen going out the back door as the audience laughs, Chang
says "The bird has flown, one of us is yellow!".
And last of all is the scene where Chang is found in the sewers not long
after he was attacked by a giant rat and he smokes opium to kill the
pain and he is found by the
Doctor and Leela and he
says to the Doctor "I singular sight I fear. It is too late, Doctor,
and I feel no pain. The opium". So, Chang explains how was a former
faithful servant to Greel before he was dismissed by him "I lay there,
Doctor, and cursed Weng-Chiang, my benefactor, who had brought me to
this fate. Hatred of him gave me the strength to drag myself away. The
rats had gone. I came here to destroy the false god. The last act of the
Great Chang!". Chang continues "I believed in him. For many years I
believed in him" and the Doctor says "It was a good act, Chang" and
Chang says "Until he shamed me. I lost face. The whole theatre saw my
failure".
And soon Chang begins to succumbs to his fatal wounds and says to the
Doctor "Soon I shall join my ancestors. Already I can see them. They
walk to greet me from the Palace of Jade. They are smiling and carry
gifts of food and flowers. Now I cross the golden bridge of the gods!".
The Doctor then tries to get Chang to tell where Greel's House of the
Dragon is located but Chang dies before he can tell him.
Roy Deep also makes a
noteworthy appearnce as the creepy Mr Sin, the dimunitive waxwork doll,
that does Greel's evil bidding.
And Roy doesn't have much dialogue except in the scene where Chang performs a magic trick on stage where he levitates a woman on stage. So, in the scene Mr Sin undermines Chang's tricks and says of the woman under his trance "She is asleep!" and Chang says "She it not asleep, Mr Sin!" and Mr Sin says "She smoked pipe of poppy!" which prompts laughter from the audience. And as Chang has two tables removed that appear to prop the woman up, Mr Sin says "She is lying on metal bar!" and Chang says "She doesn't lie on metal bar!". And as Chang levitates the woman into the air, Mr Sin says "She held up by wires!" and Chang then takes a sword and threatens Mr Sin by holding it close to him, prompting shock from the audience and Mr Sin shouts "Don't touch me! Help! Police! Murder!". So, Chang then stands back and sweeps the sword around the woman's body and says "You see no wires, Mr Sin!".
And last of all is Michael Spice as the villainous Greel, who
we never see his face until the climax at the end of episode five where
Leela unmasks him, and we see his twisted features. Spice plays a great
villain, especially with his impressive booming voice and no doubt it
would have scared many a kid back then.
And Spice has his share of good scenes such as his first one where Chang
meets with Greel in his lair underground. So, in the scene Greel is
clearly weak as he coughs and moves slowly and he says to Chang "You are
late!" and Chang warns him "We should not go tonight, Lord" but Greel
insists "I must, every night until the time cabinet found!" and he
coughs loudly. Greel then tells Chang "You must bring another linnet to
my cage! The disease grows worse. Each distillation lasts less than the
time before".
Chang warns Greel though as the girls keep disappearing there is the
danger the police will get closer to them. So, Greel tells Chang "Bah.
Those dumb-witted oxen. Chang, I have given you mental powers undreamt
of in this century. You are thousands of years ahead of your time! What
can you fear from these primitives?!". Chang then tells Greel about the
Doctor but Greel dismisses the idea that he might be a possible time
agent from the future "A time agent would not ask questions. A time
agent would know!". Chang then tells Greel of the Doctor "If he troubles
us further, I will deal with him personally" and Greel says "Very well.
We're wasting time. Come!".
And there is the scene where Chang brings two more girls to Greel's lair
so he can drain their life essences to keep him alive. And Chang looks
at the girls, one of which is Leela in disguise and Chang says "They're
not the best but they will do. They're young. Their life essence is
still strong" and he feels Leela's arms and exclaims in surprise "Oh,
this one has muscles like a horse!". Chang says "I took what I could
find, Lord" and Greel chastens Chang and says "I have given you
knowledge. I have made you a leader among your fellows. All I have asked
for in return is a few contemptible slatterns who will never be
missed!". Greel then tells Chang to leave him to his work and after
Chang leaves, Greel turns to Leela and says to her "I shall not keep you
waiting long!".
Then there is the scene where Greel activates the distillation chamber
to drain the cleaning girl's life essence and Leela attacks Greel by
surprise but is too late to save the girl. So, Leela manages to escape
only to have Greel bang his gong to
summon his large rats in the sewers and he yells "When my beauties find
her, she will wish she died HERE!!".
Spice naturally has some good
scenes in the story such as the scene where Jago and Litefoot stumble on
his lair at the house of the dragon. And he says to them when they
arrive "So you choose to pry on the house of the dragon. Unwise, very
unwise!" and later he nearly chokes Jago to death in forcing him to try
and tell him where the bag is with the time key for his time cabinet and
then says "You will die later slowly! It will give pleasure to my
wolves!".
Another good scene from Spice
comes when he finally has retrieved the time key and places it in his
time cabinet, which runs on Zigma energy (which was said to be highly
unstable and the result of Greel's deformity).So, Greel excitedly says
"Perfect. Perfect! After all these years the function is unimpaired!
Everything exactly as it was. The parallax synchrons fully charged, the
strata tube set at maximum!". Greel then laughs maniacally and shouts
"He was wrong! WRONG!! The Zigma experiment was a
success!!!".
And last of all there is the classic line where Greel places
Leela in his distilation chamber and says "Whatever it was there will
be no escape for you. Let the talons of Weng-Chiang shred your FLIIIIESSHHH!!".
DIRECTOR AND MUSIC
Moving onto the director, David Maloney does a great job here as he
had already directed some of the show's most acclaimed serials such as
The War Games and Genesis of the Daleks and he paces out the story very
well here and keeps the action and story moving along nicely even for a
six parter. This was in actual fact the last Doctor Who story that
Maloney would have directed, which was a pity given how great his
serials were in the series. Maloney himself later died in 2006, aged 72.
As for one amusing fact about the making of the show was that for one of the scenes show on the streets, there was one shot where a modern car was in shot. However the production team where unable to contact the owner to have it moved, so they ended up covering it over with hay! You can spot it easily, as you see the shape of the car beneath!
As for the music score it is by Dudley Simpson, which is once again great, as Simpson, who by this time had been a real veteran score writer for the show virtually since it began (his first music score for the show was back in 1964 in the Hartnell era, Planet of Giants) and Simpson himself makes a cameo in the story as a conductor at the theatre. Simpson's score has plenty of dramatic passages throughout and I really like the use of some of the organ music, especially when Chang is negotiating the bowels of the theatre to reach the sewer to meet with Greel.
FLAWS (Warning: this section may refer to spoilers!)
As
for Talons flaws??? Well its a great story but there are still the odd
niggles here and there.
And the biggests flaws that can be levelled at the story is of
course the inclusion of the giant rat,
which is basically pretty silly, and is not menacing at all, as it just
looks like a man in a mouse costume (which is pretty much what it is!).
I also felt that perhaps the story threatens choke itself on its own
cleverness at times and the intellectual dialogue between Jago and
Litefoot at times becomes a bit drawn out as they appear to try and
outdo each other on who has larger vocabulary! But that doesn't take
away from the great chemistry they share as an unlikely duo involved in
fighting crime. This is also in part probably due to the story writer, Robert Holmes, who collected dictionaries and loved to show off his flair for the language in his writing.
Another niggle probably comes from Greel's make-up when
his face is revealed after Leela pulls off his mask as it might appear
scary to young children (well maybe not today!) but it actually appears
pretty silly for the most part, especially given that how can Greel
speak so clearly given his twisted features! So, yeah I think the make-up is a bit inconsistent with how Greel could speak so freely given that his mouth is twisted out of shape but ah well.
And as villain whilst
Greel is quite effective, his ranting and raving does become a bit
tiresome after a while especially as he keeps berating his coolies who
are trying to do their best to find the bag holding the time key and he
instead yells "You incompetent lice! You mindless crawling dogs!". But
again these are fairly minor niggles and I'm maybe just nitpicking here
(with the exception of giant rat of course!).
Anyway that's it for the flaws.
SUM UP
So to sum up, The Talons of Weng Chiang remains one
of the great classics of the original show, and one of Tom Baker's
finest stories. It was a shame that Philip Hinchcliffe decided to part
company with the show at that point as his tenure on the series proved
to be what quite a few fans called the Golden Age of the show. And some
might even say that Doctor Who was never the same again after that, which in a way it wasn't but then again, I guess the show had to be ready for a new tenure and new producer at some point.
So, I will give The Talons of Weng-Chiang a rating of:
10 out of 10
So, that's it for now and I will be back soon with another post.
Till, then its bye for now!
No comments:
Post a Comment