So, for this post, I've done something a bit different than usual, as I will look at a film I've reviewed before but not in its original version and the film is Superman II, as there is an alternate version that was put together by original film director, Richard Donner. Donner himself worked on Superman II before he was fired by the producers, the Salkinds and was replaed by Richard Lester.
So, with this reimagning of the sequel, let's take a look and see how it fairs to the original sequel itself...
And the usual warning is coming...
PLOT SPOILERS AHEAD!!! (Plus, the story does alternate from the original film to an extent)
STORY
So, the story begins with a recap of the first film and Superman pushing one of Lex's rockets into space that would have destroyed New Jersey, which in this version causes the three Kryptonian criminals lead by General Zod (Terence Stamp) to be freed from their eternal prison, the phantom zone (in the original it was an Eiffel tower elevator that was rigged with explosives).
So, as a result of the explosion, the three villains
from
the first film, the ruthless General Zod, his aid Ursa
(Sarah Douglas) and the mindless thug Non (Jack
O'Halloran) (who appear during the opening trial scene) are released
from the
phantom zone, and to make matters worse, because they are Kryptonians
too, they have the same powers as Superman. And its not long before
they arrive on Earth and wreak absolute havoc, destroying anyone
and anything in their way, with their super powers.
However while this
is going on, Clark Kent/Superman is oblivious as he is on an assignment
with Lois Lane and they are sent by the Daily Planet to Niagra Falls to
investigate honeymoon hotel scams. During their trip, Lois grows
suspicious of Clark's behaviour as he conveniently disappears when a
young boy falls into the Niagra Falls, only to have Superman fly out
seconds later to save him. Initially Clark manages to bluff Lois, but in this version, she tricks Clark into revelaing his true identity as she fires a gun at him, which was loaded with blanks. Clark
finally changes into Superman and leaves with Lois and they fly off to the Fortress of Solitude, where
Superman explains his real background to Lois.
Clearly Superman and Lois are in love with each other, and Superman talks with the image of his father, Kal-El (Marlon Brando) and declares his love for Lois, but he warns Superman if he chooses Lois he must become human. Superman agrees and steps into a molecule chamber, which removes his powers, on leaving the chamber, Clark and Lois go off to begin their new relationship.
While this is all going on by now, Zod, Ursa and Non invade the Whitehouse and forced the President to surrender his power over to them. So, as the President submits to Zod, he pleads "Oh, God" only for Zod to correct him "Zod!".
Meanwhile Clark and Lois go off to a diner (driving by car this time!) and Clark soon finds out when he stands up to a crude trucker, Rocky (Pepper Martin) that he is indeed vulnerable, as Rocky beats him up with ease. At this point, Clark sees Zod on the TV with the President who declares he has given his power over to Zod. Clark then realises, having made a terrible mistake in giving up his powers, that he must go back, but the process of losing his powers is apparently irreversible. Nevertheless, Clark goes back to the fortress, and appeals to his father, but receives no response but as he is about to leave, he spots the green crystal that created the fortress embedded in the ground, which he places into a control chamber, bringing the visage of Jor-El to life again. Jor-El tells Clark, that they will never see each other again and uses his power to restore Clark's powers.
Meanwhile Lex Luthor, having escaped prison,
makes an uneasy alliance with Zod, who flies to the Daily Planet to take
Lois hostage to force Superman out in the open. And pretty soon the
caped wonder flies back on the scene and challenges Zod and his two
underlings as the four of them proceed to battle it out.....
THOUGHTS
Superman
II: The Richard Donner Cut is a curious but still highly enjoyable film, that sees the use of a lot of unused footage that was directed by Donner himself as well as some alternate takes of existing scenes as well as some new effects. Donner however still had to make use of a certain amount of Richard Lester's footage in order to make film somewhat more cohesive but it still has to be said the film is still a bit disjointed feeling at times and the shift in tone between the two directors is still apparent, albeit less so in this version. What Donner does manage to do is cut down on the slapstick that Lester put in the original version, which is good in itself as it was something Lester would go on to abuse in Superman III.
PERFORMANCE AND NOTABLE SCENES (Warning: this section is BIG and will contain spoilers!)
As for the performances well they are pretty much all excellent starting with Christopher Reeve who
is once again terrific in his dual role as Superman and Clark
Kent and he nicely balances Superman's heroism and Clark's bumbling nature.
Reeve has plenty of highlights and good scenes in the film that include
his opening scene where Clark speaks to his editor and boss Perry White
(Jackie Cooper) at the Daily planet, where Lois susses out that Clark is in fact Superman after all, as she looks at a picture of him in the newpaper and draws over it to make it look like Clark.
So, in the scene, after Perry speaks to both of them and leaves his office for a minute, Clark looks at Lois and says to her "Wow, you look like the cat that caught the canarie this morning!" and Lois teases him and says "The canary?! No, I was thinking of something bigger that flies and in blue". Clark looks puzzled and says "Well, as usual, I'm in the dark with all this" and Lois says "Well, let me turn the lights on for you!" and she shows him the photo of Superman, which Lois has drawn over to make it look like Clark. So, Clark says "You know that's funny, Lois!" and Lois says "I gotta admit, a good reporter never let's a story by them but you had me fooled and I am nobody's fool" and she looks at him and says "Superman". Clark laughs nervously and says "You really think I'm Superman?!" and Lois says "Willing to bet my life on it!" and she throws away her pen and goes over to the open window. Clark then takes the paper and looks at it and tries to laugh it off and says "Lois, you know are a priceless!" but then sees Lois at the window and nervously says "Lois, what are you doing?!" and Lois says "You wouldn't let me die, would you, Superman!" and she jumps out the window.
Clark then with super speed, runs down outside the Daily Planet and uses his super power breath to slow down Lois's fall and he uses his heat vision to open the Daily Planet canopy, which Lois bounces off and lands face down on a fruit stall outside the DP building. So, Lois dazed looks up and sees Clark back up above and Clark says "Lois, what are you doing?!" and Lois shocked says "Clark..." and she faints. So, at this point, a DP worker walks into Perry's office and asks where Lois is and Clark smiles and says "Oh, she stepped out for a moment".
Then there is the scene where Lois is suspicious of Clark being Superman and challenges him while they are at Niagra falls and to prove the point she jumps into the water below and get's carried off by the rapids.
Then later there is the scene where Clark and Lois after he has lost his super powers, go to a diner where Clark is beaten up by a rough customer, Rocky. So, in the scene Clark says to Rocky "Excuse me, sir, I think you are in my seat" and Rocky points to the toilet and says "You're seat is in there, four eyes!". So, Clark, a bit annoyed says "Gee, someone should teach you some manners, sir!" and Rocky says "Really? Let me know when he comes in!". So, Clark, now angered asks Rocky "Excuse me sir, would you care to step outside? I said would you care to step outside?!". So, Rocky get's and says to Clark "After you" and as Clark begins to walk out, Rocky punches Clark in the back and he crashes into a window. And Clark looks and sees that he is bleeding and in shock says "Blood! My blood" and he weakly says "Looks like from now on you'll have to have a bodyguard with you". And Lois says "I don't want a bodyguard I want the man I fell in love with" and Clark says "I know, Lois, I wish he were here". So, after Rocky hits Clark again and get's into a scuffle with Lois, he leaves the diner with Clark lying on the ground, Lois helps him back up.
And when Clark sees General Zod on the TV, ranting and raving and challenging Superman to meet him and bow down before him, he decides he must go back to the fortress to try and get his powers back.
So, after the diner owner shuts the TV off as Zod yells to Superman to kneel before him, Clark asks the owner "Here? When?" and the owner "Where have you been, Mac? On a desert island?!" and Clark simply nods. Clark then says to Lois "I have to go back" and Lois "But you can't go back now" but Clark insists "I HAVE to! I have to try something damn it! I have to try anything!". Lois however tries to appease him "This isn't your fault! You didn't know this was going to happen!" and Clark says of Jor-El "He knew, I heard him. I just didn't listen".
And then after this there is the scene when Clark returns to the
fortress of solitude and he makes a desparate attempt to reach out to
his father Jor-El. And Clark says "Father... if you can hear me... I failed... I've failed you, I've failed myself... and all humanity. I've traded my birthright... for a life of submission in a world ruled by your enemies... there's nobody left to help them now... the people of the world... since I... FATHER!". However after no response, Clark is about to leave when he spots the green crystal glowing in
the icy ground of the fortress and he picks it up and places it in the burnt out control device, bringing Jor-El's image back to life.
Then later is the scene where Superman returns with his powers fully
restored he flies up to the Daily planet office window just outside
White's office where Zod his seized control and Superman challenges
Zod. And in the scene Superman says "General, don't you believe in the freedom of the press?!" and Zod yells "Come to me son of Jor-El!! KNEEL BEFORE
ZOD!!!" and they fly out the window after him and begin their epic
battle in Metropolis.
Then there is the scene at the Fortress of Solitude where Superman has his final battle with Zod, Ursa and Non and they are joined by Lois and Lex Luthor. And in the scene after they fight, Superman is forced to surrender to Zod but then he talks discreetly with Luthor and says " Try and get them all into this molecule chamber. It takes away their powers, see... and turns them into ordinary human beings. Now if you could..." but Zod approaches and Superman shushes Luthor. But Luthor betrays Superman by telling Zod about the chamber and Superman angrily says "Luthor, you poisonous snake!".
And Superman is forced to go into the chamber where it activates and apparently makes him human although he still has his cape and instead Superman has in fact turned the tables on Zod and the others to make them human, which he proves by kneeling before Zod and then crushes his hand! Superman then picks up Zod and throws him away and he hits the wall and falls into a deep chasm with Non following suit as he tries to fly and Ursa is knocked into the chasm by Lois's right hook.
So, after this, Lois hugs Superman who asks her if she is alright and she nods and Superman turns to Lex and says "I knew you'd double cross me, Luthor! A lying weasel like you couldn't resist the chance!". Lex however tries to bluff his way out of it and says "You kidding?! That was beautiful! Did you see they way they fell into our trap?!" and he laughs loudly but Superman sees through it and shouts "TOO LATE, LUTHOR! Too late!" and he flies off with Lois and abandons Lex at the fortress.
And last of all is the amusing scene near the end of the film where Clark returns to the diner to get revenge over Rocky who beat him up earlier on. So, in the scene, Rocky sits in the diner munching on his meal and he shouts "Get me another plate of your garbage!" which the female worker takes offense to as its her special. So, Clark suddenly appears at the door and says "Gee, that's funny! Never seen garbage eat garbage before!" and Rocky looks over and sees Clark, who moves slowly toward him and says "Excuse me, sir, I think you're sitting in my favourite seat!" and Rocky says "Come and get it, four eyes!".
So, Clark calmly and slowly walks towards Rocky, whom the diner owner warns him that he just got the place fixed up after his last fight with Clark. So, as Clark stands in front of Rocky, who takes a swing and punches Clark in the gut only for it to have no effect and he grasps his hand in great pain. So, as Rocky sits down, Clark spins his seat around really fast, which makes him dizzy and Clark lifts him onto the counter and says to the owner "This order's to go!" and shoves him across the counter and he crashes into a pinball machine at the end of the room. Clark then offers some money to the owner and says "I'm terribly sorry about the damage, sir" and he before he goes, he says "Oh, I've been..." and he mimes lifting weights "...working out!" and he walks out.
Margot Kidder is excellent again as Lois Lane and she plays the
part to near perfection as she gives her character the right amount of
feistiness and her character is nicely developed as she falls further in
love with Superman.
Kidder some good scenes aswell that include her opening scene in the Donner cut, where Lois works out Clark is Superman after drawing over a photo of Superman in the paper and making it look like Clark. So, as Lois and Clark are called into Perry's office, Clark rushes in and says to Lois "How, are you today, Lois?" and she teases and nudges him in his side "Oh, I'm just super! Just super!". So, as Clark apologises for being late as he was caught in traffic, Lois says "Oh, that's a new one! As opposed to being caught in a phone booth or the men's room?!" and Clark surprised asks "Lois, what are you talking about?!".
So, as Perry gives them the assignment to pose as newlyweds to expose a racket scam, Lois ladels it on thick for Clark.
So, in the scene, after Perry speaks to both of them and leaves his office for a minute, Clark looks at Lois and says to her "Wow, you look like the cat that caught the canarie this morning!" and Lois teases him and says "The canary?! No, I was thinking of something bigger that flies and in blue". Clark looks puzzled and says "Well, as usual, I'm in the dark with all this" and Lois says "Well, let me turn the lights on for you!" and she shows him the photo of Superman, which Lois has drawn over to make it look like Clark. So, Clark says "You know that's funny, Lois!" and Lois says "I gotta admit, a good reporter never let's a story by them but you had me fooled and I am nobody's fool" and she looks at him and says "Superman". Clark laughs nervously and says "You really think I'm Superman?!" and Lois says "Willing to bet my life on it!" and she throws away her pen and goes over to the open window. Clark then takes the paper and looks at it and tries to laugh it off and says "Lois, you know are a priceless!" but then sees Lois at the window and nervously says "Lois, what are you doing?!" and Lois says "You wouldn't let me die, would you, Superman!" and she jumps out the window.
Then there is the scene where Lois and Clark are at Niagra falls together, so as they walk together, Clark suggests they hold hands and Lois says "Here's my hand, Clark, hold it!" and he takes her hand and they walk. So, Lois says of a couple off screen "You know why they hold hands, soon as they let go, straight to the lawyer!" and Clark says "I don't know, they look happy to me!" and Lois says "That's because your blind, Clark" and we see Clark's glasses are misted up because they are close to the falls. So, Lois takes off Clark's glasses and cleans them without looking at him and says "You've only got one pair of eyes, so you need to take care of them! So, don't say I'm not good to you..." and she looks up and sees Clark without his glances and suddenly looks surprised. Clark quickly puts his glasses back on and goes over and shouts at a boy, who mucking around on the hand rails over the falls. Lois starts to think about what she saw but then let's it go.
So, as Lois takes a picture, Lois says "You know what I'm hungry!" and Clark shakes his head and says You know, Lois, you're amazing!" and Lois asks "What?" and Clark says "Look, here we are at one of nature's most amazing spectacles and all you can think of is food! I mean, aren't you impressed?!". So, Lois says "You know, Clark, once a girl's seen Superman in action, Niargra Falls kind of leaves you cold, you know what I mean?". Clark then warily says "Him again, huh?" and Lois says "I'm sorry, I got a one track mind, don't I? Well, you know what my one track mind is telling me now, I'm hungry".
Then there is the scene, which was actually Christopher Reeve's screen test where Lois tricks Clark into revealing that he is Superman. So, in the scene, Lois shoots Clark with the gun and Clark gives in and takes off his glasses and he says "You know if that was Clark Kent, he might have been killed" and Lois holds up the gun and asks "With a blank?!" and Clark looks shocked and Lois smiles and says "Gotcha!".
Last of all is the scene near the end of the film, where after Superman reverses time by flying around the world like he did in the first film to undo the events of the movie. So, then we cut to the next morning where Lois has a weird moment thinking she has missed something and we see Clark come into the office.
So, in the scene, Lois asks Clark to get her a pizza and Clark a little taken aback looks at his watch and says "A pizza, at this time?" and Lois says "Yeah and you know what? I'll pay half" and Clark gives in and says "OK, I'm going". Clark then stops and says to Lois "You know, its OK Lois, I'll pay for the pizza" and Lois smiles and says "Thanks, Clark" and as he is about to leave she says "You know, you're really super!" and this stops Clark dead in his tracks and he cautiously remains silent and slowly walks out.
Gene Hackman is also great as Lex Luthor once again and he evidently relishes in playing the character and has his share of fun moments.
And to start off there is the scene where Luthor in jail with Otis,
laments over his failure to defeat Superman during the events of the
first film. However, Lex has already hatched a plan to try and escape
prison and locate a way to travel North to find Superman's fortress of
solitude.
So, in the scene, Otis tells Lex how every time they
try and locate Superman, he flies off North and Lex asks "Why?" and Otis
suggests "To ski?" and Lex says to him "Every man his vulnerable point.
You, Otis, have more than one! I didn't see Superman's in time. But
with time, patience and skill...my little black box is almost ready".
Otis then says loudly "Oh! That little black box in our cell?!" and Lex
loudly sushes him and Otis quietly asks "What does it do?" and Lex tells
him "That little black box goes beyond any conventional radar. It
tracks alpha waves" and Otis pretending to know what he means says
"Ahhh! Alpha waves" and Lex turns away and shakes his head in disbelief.
Lex then says "Those alpha waves will take me North to his secret and
his secret will give me Superman!".
Then there is the scene where Lex turns up at the White house after Zod, Ursa and Non have taken it over. And Luthor turns up waving a handkerchief as a peaceful gesture and he addresses himself to them "Hi, Lex Luthor. LEX LUTHOR! Possibly you've heard the name? the Greatest Criminal Mind on Earth!". And as Zod and the others move menacingly toward him Luthor backs away saying "WAIT! I can give you anything! The... the... the... the Brass Ring, unlimited freedom to maim and kill! PLUS! Lex Luthor's keen mind, Lex Luthor's savvy...." and he puts his hand on Ursa's and says "Lex Luthor's school of career guidance.." and she begins to crush it. And Luthor then reveals a valuable piece of info that might keep him alive as he says to Zod "Oh Great One, what I am bargaining with is what YOU do not have: The Son of Jor-El". And Zod says "Come! We will bring him to his knees!" and as they make to walk out Luthor stops them saying "WAIT! First you must find him... and Lex Baby is the only one who knows where he is".
Zod then waringly asks Lex "What do you want?" and Lex sits in the President's chair in the oval office and lights a cigar and says "Well, General, the word is a big place, thank goodness my needs are small. As it turns out, I have a certain weakness for beachfront property" and Zod walks back in and asks again "What do you want?" and Lex does the Nixon pose and says "Australia!".
Then there is the scene where Zod, Ursa and Non invade the Daily planet
and Non smashes his way into White's office. And after Luthor arrives
and says to himself "Even with all this accumulated knowledge, when will
these dummies learn to use a DOOR KNOB?!" and he walks into White's
office and says " Hi! You should see the White House; they'll be
cleaning it for months!". Zod however is not impressed when he sees that
Superman isn't there and says to Lex "You promised me the son of
Jor-El!" and Lex awkwardly says "Oh, your grace...what I've given you is
the next best thing! All you need to do is hold onto that little lady
there and he'll show up. They're the best of friends!" and he laughs
furtively and says "You know what I mean?".
And when Zo
threatens to kill Lex once again and orders for the others to be killed,
Superman finally shows up outside and challenges Zod.
So, at this point, Luthor
out of character shows a sign of relief and says to himself "Superman,
thank God!"
and Zod glares at him and Luthor quickly says "I mean, GET HIM!!".
And lastly is the confrontational scene at the Fortress of Solitude
where Superman whispers to Luthor about the molecule chamber and how it
can take away the supervillain's powers but Luthor decides to betray
Superman by letting him know. And Luthor says to Zod "Don't go in
there, General, its a trap. That's a molecule chamber. It turns people
like you into people like me". And after Superman has defeated the evil
trio he says to Luthor how he knew he would double cross him and Luthor
tries to backpedal and says "Are you kidding? That was beautiful!
Did you see the way they fell into our trap!" but Superman shouts "Too
late, Luthor! Too late!". Lex then tries to make one last ditch attempt
to appeal to Superman and says "Look, Superman, I know I owe you one.
But if you take me back, I promise I will turn over a whole new leaf!"
but Superman leaves Lex behind.
Marlon Brando next reappears in this Donner version, as his archival footage was approved by Brando's family estate after his death in 2004. So, this footage is interesting and also replaces the Lester footage of Susannah York used in the original film, where Superman speaks to his mother instead of Jor-El.
So, I will mention two of Brando's scenes starting with the one where Superman tells Jor-El he loves Lois and wishes to be with her despite Jor-El's pleas not to.
So, in the scene, Jor-El tells Superman that he must become a human if he wishes to live with Lois and says " If you will not be Kal-El... if you will live as one of them... love their kind as one of them... then it follows... that you must become one of them...". So, then a chamber appears and opens and Jor-El tells Superman "This crystal chamber has in it the harnessed rays of the red sun of Krypton... once exposed to them all your great powers on Earth will disappear... forever... once this is done there is no going back... you will feel like an ordinary man... and you can be harmed like an ordinary man...". So, as Superman steps toward the chamber, Jor-El pleads with him one last time "Kal-el, I beg of you... please think..." but Superman decides to step into the chamber.
Then there is the scene where Clark (or Kal-el) returns to the fortress and after he pleads, he finds the green crystal, which restore the image of Jor-el who speaks with Clark one last time.
So, in the scene Jor-El says to Clark "Listen carefully my son... for we shall never speak again... if you hear me now... then you have used the only means left to you... the crystal source in which our communications begun... the circle is now complete... you have made a dreadful mistake Kal-El... you did this of your own free will... in spite of all I could say to dissuade you...". Now you return to me for
one last chance to redeem yourself... this too I have finally
anticipated my son... look at me Kal-El... once before when you were
small I died while giving you a chance for life and even now though it
will exhust the final energy left within me". Jor-el then finishes by saying "Look at me Kal-El... the
Kryptonian prophecy will at last be fulfilled... the son becomes the
father... the father becomes the son... farewell forever... Kal-El...
remember me my son!". Then Jor-el appears in solid form and puts his hand on Clark, restoring his powers before Clark passes out.
Terence Stamp is also great as the main villain, General Zod, the
ruthless Kyrptonian who leads his group of supervillains and threatens
to take over the Earth.
Stamp has a great role and he appears to really revel in it (and why
not?!) and he has his fair share of great moments that include the scene
where Zod, Ursa and Non kill a NASA space crew on the moon as they talk about their great new powers.
So,
in the scene Ursa says to Zod "Something is happening" and Zod says
"Yes, to all of us. The closer we come to a planet with one sun, a
yellow sun. The more our molecular density gives us unlimited powers".
Ursa then says "They come from there. A place called Houston" and Zod
says to her "Then we will go there to rule. Finally to rule!" and they
take off and head for Earth.
Then as the trio arrive in a small town in America and they wreak havoc as the army turn up but they defeat the army easily. And Zod says after Ursa destroys a helicopter by blowing at it "I win! I ALWAYS win! Is there no one even on this planet that will challenge me?!!".
And
then after Zod announces on himself on television and he says to one of
the army generals "
So you are a General? And who is your superior?!" and the General says
"I only answer to the president" and Zod angrily says "And he will
answer to ME! Or else all his cities will end up like this one!" and he
rips off the general's star from the shoulder of his uniform and throws
it away.
Another good scene for Stamp is when Zod, Ursa and Non invade the White
house and they enter the oval office and Zod confronts the president.
And one man steps forward and Zod says to him "Now kneel before Zod" and
the man obediently kneels straight away and Zod says "You are not the
president. No one who leads so many would kneel so quickly" and the
real president (E.G. Marshall) then reveals himself and says "I will
kneel before if it will save lives" and Zod says "It will, starting with
your own". And the president says "What I do now, I do for the sake of
the people of Earth. But there is one man on this planet who will NEVER
kneel before you" and Zod says the great line "Who is this imbecile?
Where is he?" and the president says "I wish I knew" and he kneels
saying "Oh God" and Zod unwittingly corrects him "Zod!".
Then there is the big fight scene between Zod and Superman in Metropolis
and Superman turns up and asks him to step outside and Zod shouts out
"Come to me, son of Jor-El!! KNEEL BEFORE ZOD!!" and he flies smashing
through the window as do Ursa and Non. And in the scene Superman flies
to a building site and Zod lands on a building across from him and says
"Son of Jor-El, we were beginning to think you were a coward!" and
Superman says "I'm not a coward, Zod" and Zod uses his heat vision
powers to break off the side of a building and he grabs with both hands
and aims to launch it at Superman and shouts "Then die as you deserve
to!" and he throws it at Superman who destroys it with his heat vision.
And later there is the final confrontation at the Fortress of Solitude
where Zod and the others finally arrive and force Superman to accept defeat. So, after Superman is forced to step
into the molecule chamber and it activates, Superman steps out looking
weak and he moves toward Zod who says "And now... finally. Take my hand
and swear eternal loyalty to Zod" and Superman takes Zod's hand and
crushes it and lifts him up and throws him into the chasm below!
And the last few cast members I will mention include Sarah Douglas who
is good as Ursa, Zod's villainous second in command. Interesting
enough, Douglas's dialogue was mostly dubbed over by Annie Ross, who
appeared in Superman III as the villainous Vera Webster. However in the Donner cut, Douglas's real voice is occasionally used but not often.
And Douglas has some good moments also that include the scene on the moon where Ursa walks up to one of the US astronauts on a lunar mission. So, Ursa asks the astronaut "You?! What sort of creature are you?" and the astronaut says "Just a man" and Ursa amused asks "A man?" and she suddenly notices the NASA symbol on his spacesuit and she tries to grab it and he suddenly moves away. So, Ursa flies after him and lands in front of him and rips the symbol off, which causes his suit to inflate and Ursa kicks him far away into space.
Then there is the scene where just after
the supervillains arrive on Earth in the woods and Ursa picks up a
snake and says "A primitive creature of sorts" and it bites her and she uses her heat vision to kill it and in
surprise she says "Did you see that? Did you see what I did? I have
powers beyond reason here!" and Zod replies "We all have them, my dear".
Then there is the scene where Zod and Ursa walk into a bar and survey it
and notices two men doing an arm wrestle and the winner looks over at
Ursa leeringly. And Ursa walks over to him and sits down and holds out
her hand to wrestle and she smiles saying "Let's just hold hands" and
the man takes her hand and says "Let me know if this tickles!" and Ursa
swiftly twists his arms and knocks him off the table which breaks in
half.
And then there is the scene just after where a television crew have
arrived to report on the havoc wreaked by Zod and the others but Zod
then steps out and tells him to continue his report. However Ursa
quickly get's fed up and says "Enough of this! If the whole planet is
watching, cannot we show them something more interesting?!". And as the
army show up and a major orders them to surrender and "This is an
order!" Ursa says "General Zod does not take orders! He gives them!".
And lastly there is the scene where Zod, Ursa and Non invade the Daily
planet offices and they find White and Lois and Ursa mockingly says of
Superman "What an undemanding male this Superman must be!". And Lois
retorts "Yeah, and you could use a tuck here and there yourself,
sister!" and Ursa moves at her but Zod stops her.
Jackie Cooper is also pretty good in his role as Perry White, the tough no nonsense editor of the Daily planet.
Cooper also has some good moments although they are adjusted from the original version due to Donner removing the sequence where Superman flies to Paris to get rid of the bomb placed in the Eiffel tower. So, instead, there is a scene where Perry calls Lois and Clark into his office and tells them that he is sending on a story to pose as newly weds.
So, as Lois teases Clark not so subtly about being Superman, Clark irritated asks "Lois, what are you talking about?!" and Perry says "Well since you're bickering, I'm gonna send you on a story as newlyweds to expose a honeyroom racket! You know they squeeze these poor kids for evert cent they've got". Clark however protests but Lois teases him more and says "Oh, that's a GREAT idea, Mr White! I mean we could fly up there and fly down in no time! You know...Superman?" and she looks at Clark again. Perry then unaware of Lois's teasing says "Yeah, if he could give you a ride, maybe we could save a couple of bucks!".
Jack O'Halloran even though he has no dialogue at all in the film
given that his character is mute does well as Non, the not-too-bright
supervillain who likes to wreak havoc, chaos and destruction. And
O'Halloran best moments come when he tests out his heat vision against a
truck in the small town and he starts to get the hang of using it and
he looks pleased with himself and later as the army attack he uses the
heat vision to full strength and destroys an army truck with it and he
grins and looks to Zod, who looks fairly impressed.
And lastly there is the scene where the supervillains invade the offices
of the Daily planet and Non literally smashes his way into Perry
White's office. And Non then walks right up to Perry's desk and Perry
makes a feeble attempt to hit Non as he picks up his atlas globe and
throws it at Non and it simply bounces off his head and Non smashes
Perry's desk in half and he grabs him and lifts him up to the ceiling
and puts his head through the roof, knocking Perry out.
And the last few I will mention starts with Ned Beatty who
has fun reprising his role as Lex Luthor's dim-witted sidekick, Otis.
Beatty only really appears early on in the film while Lex is still in prison but he some good moments that include the scene where Otis does laundry and he tells Lex that Superman always travels North. And Luthor muses "North... Why does he always go north?" and Otis offers a suggestion "To skie?!". Lex then muses "Every man has his vulnerable point, some men like you, Otis, have more than one! But I failed to see Superman's in time, but with time my little black box is almost ready". Otis then says loudly "Oh! That little black box in our cell!" and Lex loudly shushes him and Otis quietly says "That little black box in our cell, Mr Luthor, what does it do?". Lex then quietly tells Otis "That little black box, Otis, goes way beyond any conventional radar. It tracks alpha waves" and Otis, none the wiser nods as if he understands and says "Alpha waves!" and Lex turns his back and shakes his head.
And later there is the scene where Luthor and
Otis try to escape the prison and out in the yeard, Luthor tells Otis "Look out for the signal" and Otis "What signal?" and Luthor says "You'll know it when you see it!". So, as Otis walks out, he passes a ladder, which hits him in the face and he asks Lex "What is it?" and Lex says "Its a ladder, you dummy!". So as Miss Teschmacher turns up in air balloon for them
both and Luthor climbs up the ladder but as Otis tries to climb onboard
his weight causes the balloon to sink leaving Luthor to kick the ladder
off and leaving Otis behind with the guards surrounding him.
Valerie Perrine is also reprises her role very well as Miss
Teschmacher, Luthor's assistant and girlfriend who helps Luthor escape
from prison. And Perrine has a good moment when Luthor and Teschmacher
arrive at the Fortress of Solitude and Miss Teschmacher subtly drops the
hint that she needs to go to the toilet. And Luthor says to her "Its
beautiful! I has everything!" and Miss Teschmacher says "Wrong!" and she
gives him a look that tells him she needs the loo and he asks "Why
didn't you go before we left?" and Miss Teschmacher sharply says "That
was two days ago!".
Then after Lex tries a few Krypton crystals, he finds one where Jor-El sends a warning meant for Superman about General Zod. So, then Lex sees Miss Teschmacher is nowhere to be seen and he shouts after her and we hear a flushing noise and she shouts off screen "I found it!!! I think!!".
And last of all is Marc McClure who also reprises his role the
young Daily planet photographer, Jimmy Olsen.
And McClure's role is quite small here but I will mention the one scene where Lois anxiously awaits the return of Superman from the Fortress of Solitude to fight against Zod, Ursa and Non. So, in the scene, Jimmy tries to reassure Perry and Lois that Superman will turn up "I bet he's on his way here now, chief. Lois knows his plays better than anybody!" and Lois, worried, says "Yeah...better than anybody". And then we hear a large rumble as the office shakes violently and Jimmy says "It sounds like an earthquake!".
Last of all, I will mention a funny scene that was added into the Donner version where during the Superman and Zod trio fight, Jimmy comes in with a coffee that was meant for Perry, however, Lex grabs it off him instead. So, Jimmy says to Lex "That was the chief's" and Lex grins and says "The chief's got it!".
DIRECTOR(S)
Finally moving onto the direction, unusually this time round there were
two involved given that Richard Donner worked originally on the first
Superman, he also filmed a large amount of Superman II aswell as the two
films were initially to be shot back to back. However Donner had run
into some problems with the film's producers Alexander and Ilya Salkind
and Pierre Spengler off screen and he was then replaced by Richard
Lester who had previously directed two of the Salkind's films with
production being halted during 1977 and restarted again under Lester's
direction in 1979.
And it safe to say that you can easily notice the shift in tone of the
film due to the change of directors as Donner's scenes have a more
grounded and serious tone to them even though they have humour as well.
However Lester's scenes have a more slapstick and comical feel the tone
of those scenes are generally more light hearted which can be seen as
both a criticism but also in a way plus. Its difficult to say which
director provides the better effort here as both of them brought
something valuable to the film despite their different styles so overall
Donner and Lester both did a commendable job in putting Superman II
together.
As for the Donner cut itself, directorial wise, Donner still had to use some of Lester's original film footage in order to keep it more cohesive overall but he heavily removed much of slapstick that was in Lester's version. Donner was also able to obtain archived footage of Marlon Brando from Brando's family estate after his death in 2004 that allowed him to expand on the fortress of solitude scenes involving Superman and Clark Kent. So, overall this is a solid effort from Donner to restore his vision of the film even if it still feels a bit uneven at times in terms of its mix of his own footage and Lester's.
MUSIC
Also as for the music score, which here is both composed by John Williams and Ken Thorne, who was the original composer for Superman II. However, Donner was keen to use Williams to compose a new score for his version but Williams turned him down as he was busy working on the Star Wars prequel, The Revenge of the Sith at the time. Donner instead re-used Williams's original score with some alternate tracks that were never used but he also used some of Thorne's tracks as well but only gave him credit at the end of the film and Williams was given the main title credit for the soundtrack.
So, overall, its a good score in a collective sense with much of the originial movie's score (i.e. Superman: the Movie that is) that we can all identify with and either way, its great to hear Williams's actual score than Ken Thorne's (no offence to Ken as his was not bad!).
FLAWS
As for the film's flaws.....yes the Donner cut has some worth mentioning.
So to start off, I think one problem is to do with how disjointed the Donner cut feels at times, especially with the use of Christopher Reeve's screen test for the scene where Lois tricks Clark into revealing his identity. The fact is they are both dressed so differently in the scene as well, although it does somehow manage to refer to a previous scene in Superman II where Superman rescues the boy at Niagra falls, which is handy! However, it just looks completely out of place from the rest of the film and as such it doesn't fit right.
Its also worth noting you can clearly see the difference in footage between Donner and Lester's footage as they were two years apart and Margot Kidder in particular looks quite different throughout both sets of footage. So, again it does highlight a somewhat jarring difference between the two that looks quite odd and feels again a bit out of place.
Another issue is to do with some of the dialogue overdubs, as they can be pretty inconsistent and in some scenes they really feel off. One prime example is the scene where Clark rescues Lois without turning into Superman at the Daily Planet as she jumps out the window to force Clark to change into Superman. So, as Lois lands in a fruit stand, she looks up and we see a clearly fake looking Clark says to Lois "Lois, what have you done?!" which just looks really weird and out of place. To be honest, I think they shouldn't have bothered with that scene but I guess they must have not filmed Clark originally for that part.
Another odd change is where Superman returns to Metropolis to fight Zod, Ursa and Non and rather than show Supe fly up to the window outside Perry's office, they show him standing on a flagpole instead. Plus, they change Superman's much better line "General, would you care to step outside" to "General, have you not heard of the freedom of the press?!" which is really lame by comparison and definitely not one of the better changes.
Further to this, I also felt this scene where Clark rescues Lois without turning into Superman was a bit silly, as he is seen on the street using his breath to keep Lois afloat and also using his heat vision powers IN FULL VIEW OF THE PUBLIC!! So, Clark here uses his heat vision (which somehow never seems to melt his glasses!) and there clearly are a few bystanders that can see him and never think anything of it! So, yeah this was a bit daft to say the least, the scene itself is good but that last bit is just a bit dumb.
Then we have the scene, which appears in both versions, so I might as well mention it here, which is where Lois starts to suspect that Clark is in
fact Superman after he conveniently disappears when the boy falls into
the Niagara falls. And despite the fact that the boy fell into the falls
some 15 or 20 seconds before Clark managed to change into Superman
suggests that the kid would hit the water before Superman realistically
would have been able to change and fly in to rescue him! So basically
the boy should have been dead by the time Superman would have got to
him!
Another daft moment for me was just how did Zod and his underlings know
how to get to the White house?! I don't image they stopped to ask
anyone for directions! Its just like they have a built-in GPS or its
part of their super powers to know just where to find it! But again its
just something that is taken for granted in these superhero films that
the villains always just know where to go without a single hint or
clue! It would have been fun if Zod stopped and asked one of the
generals or soldiers "How do you get to this White house?!" it might
have been daft but it would have been a bit more logical.
Its also a bit strange that Miss Teschmacher suddenly disappears from
the film later on as she only appears in the earlier scenes at the
prison breakout and the FOS and it makes you wonder what happened to
her???? Also its strange how Luthor decided to trust Miss Teschmacher
again after she betrayed him in the first film by saving Superman from
drowning in the pool after Luthor put the chain of Kryptonite around his
neck. But I guess at this point he had little choice and decided he
needed her help to break out anyway.
I also thought there was a weird inconsistency in the display of the supervillains strengths and this particularly notable in the scene where Non smashes his way into the Daily Planet and some office staff try to stop him but he just brushes them aside. However, earlier we saw Zod do this as he pushed aside a man in a diner and he went right through the wall but in Non's scene, he merely brushes the office staffers to the side and they DON'T go through the wall, which you really think given Non's strength they should have!
Then we hae the scene that raises a rather morally dubious point about Superman killing people as he clearly kills off Zod at the end as he crushes his hand, picks him up and throws him into the chasm of nothingness below in the fortress. And Lois Lane does the exact same to Ursa as she punches her into the chasm as well, making her a murdered aswell but its something that never causes a problem for her and she never questions herself after (well Superman reverses time anyway, which undoes her action). However, there was apparently a deleted scene where Zod, Ursa and Non did survive and where arrested by the arctic police.
Further to this there is also the issue of Superman in the Donner version destroying the fortress of solitude with his heat vision, now having left Lex behind, does that mean Lex was still in there and was killed?? Its seems a bit strange that Superman would do that but then he has effectively just killed Zod, so why not Lex too? However, he does his time reversal trick later on, so none of this really matters.
And last of all we come to what maybe the film's most daft and illogical moment, where Superman reuses the trick to reverse time before the events of the film even happened and Zod, Ursa and Non all end up back in the phantom zone again. Now, this creates quite a few narrative problems, first off, the rocket used to free the trio was frome the FIRST film, so this would undo all the events prior to Superman II in the first place, which is REALLY taking things much further back, which makes no sense. Plus by this happening, it suggests, Superman still has to deal with the other rocket that deals damage in California, so did he reverse that too! Basically, Donner is reverting the series of events to where before or around Lex uses his high frequency signal message to lure Superman to his underground layer.
Also further to this, it also raises another big continuity error, where Clark returns to the diner to get revenge on Rocky for beating him up earlier. Now, if Superman reverses time to before this ever happened, he would never have even met Rocky in the first place, so how does this make ANY sense at all?! Basically that final scene should never have been in the film in the first place by that rationale, unless Clark went to the diner BEFORE he reversed time, but its not shown in that way timeline wise. So, yeah using the time reversal trick again is hugely flawed here. Plus, surely time reversal does not undo the actions, it just means its reversed to BEFORE IT HAPPENS! So, surely these actions WILL happen again! Time reversal surely isn't the same as action prevention!
Oh and one last note on all this time reversal stuff, then we have the stupid moment where Perry is about to brush his teeth and put tooth paste on his tooth brush only for it to go slowly back in the tube. So, this is obviously metaphorical and refers to the saying of putting the tooth paste back in the tube, which means that such an action is impossible and cannot be reversed (unless you ARE Superman!!). So, yep, this is definitely a silly moment in the film.
Anyway that's it for the flaws.
SUM UP
So, to sum up, the Donner cut is an interesting re-imagining of the film and its alternate footage is great to see and also includes some good scenes, particularly the beginning and end scenes for Lois and Clark and the restored footage of Jor-el is good to see as well. This also gives Clark's restoration of his powers a more full and satisfying conclusion rather than him picking up the green crystal and cut away. The cut however does have some issues with some weird voice over dubs as well as the use of Reeve's screen test, which feels out of place not to mention the time reversal trick making no sense whatsoever again!
However with that all said, the Donner cut is still worth a look and while I prefer the original Lester version as a film, its still an interesting look at what Superman II could have been had Donner not been fired from the project.
So, I will rate the Donner Cut:
8 out of 10
Right, so I will be back hopefully soon another post.
Until then its bye for now!

