So, its time for another post and this will be a revisit again but with a slight difference, rather than covering a good quality film (or game!) I'll be taking a look at a film that has been much maligned over the years. So, the film in question is Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, which was Christopher Reeve's swansong in the role but it ended on a critical and commerical low point for him.
However, given that the film is almost 40 years old, I have to ask: is it as
bad as they say it is???? Well let's dawn the red cape and find out...
And yep for what its worth there will be as usual some...
SPOILERS AHEAD!!!!!
STORY
Right OK so a bit about the plot which begins with Superman (Christopher
Reeve) saving a Russian astronaut
(or cosmonaut if you like) who falls deep into space as well as the
cosmonauts ship which was drifting off course. Superman then returns to
Smallville and as Clerk Kent visits his adopted parents farm, who have
now both passed away. Clark while in the farm's barn finds his green
Kryptonite crystal which he hid in the capsule that brought him to
Earth. Clark is then visited by a mall developer who wants to buy out
the farm but he refuses to sell and he makes his way back to
Metropolis. On returning to the Daily planet newspaper offices, Clark
learns that the paper has gone bankrupt and has now been taken over by a
tabloid tycoon, David Warfield (Sam Wanamaker) who fires the current
editor, Perry White (Jackie Cooper) and replaces him with his daughter
Lacy (Mariel Hemingway).
Not long after there is news that the United States and the Soviet Union
may engage in nuclear war leaving Clark in turmoil over how much
Superman should intervene and he receives a letter from a concerned
schoolboy, which prompts Superman to travel to the fortress of solitude
to discuss it with the spirit of his Kryptonian elders. However they
suggest Superman leave the people of Earth to resolve the situation
themselves or travel that he travel to and settle on another world where
war is not an issue.
Clark then invites his fellow reporter Lois Lane
(Margot Kidder) around to his apartment where he takes her outside and
walks off the roof with her, changing into Superman he takes her for a
flight and afterward asks what he should do and Lois says he should do
what feels right. Then in order to maintain his secret identity from
Lois, Superman kisses her to erase her memory of their meeting.
Afterward Superman then attends the United Nations and gives a speech
where he announces he will rid the world of all nuclear weapons. This
leads to various nations firing their nuclear weapons into space where
Superman grabs them and places them in a giant net and then hurls them
into the sun.
In the meantime, criminal mastermind, Lex Luthor (Gene Hackman) breaks
out of prison with the help of his nephew Lenny (John Cryer) and he
returns to Metropolis where Luthor breaks into a museum exhibit
containing a strand of Superman's hair, which he steals. Luthor then
uses the hair to create a genetic matrix which he discreetly attaches to
a test nuclear missile which is launched into space and is intercepted
by Superman who throws it into the sun. However the result of the
explosion causes the birth of nuclear man (Mark Pillow) a superhuman who
flies back to Earth under the control of Luthor, he arrives at Luthor's
hideout.
Luthor however also reveals that Nuclear man is powered by
solar polar and when he is in the shade he will be disabled. Luthor
then lures Superman into meeting his creation where Superman engages in a
fierce fight with the supervillain which includes them fighting at the
great wall of China and later in New York where Nuclear man throws the
Statue of Liberty toward the ground, which is saved by Superman.
However Nuclear man then scratches Superman with his radioactive claws
which weakens him and falls ill with radiation sickness as Nuclear man
kicks Superman away, the superhero loses his cape.
Lois later turns up at Clark's apartment where she finds him not well
from the effects of the radiation and having salvaged Superman's cape,
she gives it to Clark. Clark then manages to use the kyrptonite crystal
to revive himself and he soon returns as Superman where he confronts
Nuclear man, who has a crush on Lacy and threatens mayhem if he is not
introduced to her and this leads into their final confrontation.....
THOUGHTS
There is not any doubt that Superman IV: The quest for peace is easily
the weakest of all the original Superman films as it is poorly put together and it
clearly lacks the budget the previous films had it as its special
effects look very cheap and its story is mediocre at best. The film also suffered from the fact that the producers from the first
three films, Alexander and Ilya Salkind felt the series had ran its
course, which left the rights being sold to Menahem Golan and Yoram
Globus of the company, Cannon films and apparently during shooting they
had run out of money with the film itself having a meagre budget of $17
million.
Regardless of that though despite its faults the film itself
is still strangely enjoyable even if it is pretty mediocre it still has some
entertaining moments (such as Superman fight scenes with Nuclear man
and Clark's ducking and diving between being Superman and being
interviewed as Supe for Lois and being on a date with Lacy as Clark).
PERFORMANCES AND NOTABLE SCENES
Which brings me onto the performances which are not bad but a bit of a mixed bag.
Starting with Christopher Reeve who does very well again in his role as Superman/Clark Kent but because the material he has been given is so poor it hampers his performance rather than help it.
Still there are
some good moments in Reeve's performance such as the scene where Lois
shows Clark at the Daily planet, the paper headline of Superman
allegedly saying to the concerned school boy, Jeremy, "Superman says
drop dead kid!". And in the scene it leaves Clark in a worried state as
he walks off over to the windows to contemplate his next move. Then
there are some laughable but enjoyable moments all the same such as the
one where Superman saves a Metropolis subway train from being derailed
after the driver takes ill. And afterward Superman says to the subway
crowds "I would like our civilians to know that our subway system is
still the most safe and reliable form of transportation".
Then there is the scene where Superman addresses the United nations and
he says to the audience "So I have decided, effective immediately, that I
am going to rid the world of all nuclear weapons" leaving the audience
cheering. Reeve also occassionally has the odd fun moment as Clark as
well such as the scene at the gym where Clark does a workout with Lacy
who fancies Clark. And in the scene Clark meets an annoying gym worker
who teases him and at the end of the scene Clark easily lifts and
accidentally throws some heavy weights at the worker and Clark says
"Ummm, no pain no gain???".
Another amusing but silly scene comes when
Superman takes a flight with Lois after revealing his identity to her
and he says to her "Sometimes I don't know what I'm supposed to do" and
Lois tells him "You'll do the right thing, you always have" and they
kiss afterward which erases Lois's memory of their meeting.
Then there are the laughable scenes where Superman fights with Nuclear
man and the funniest moment comes (SPOILER FOR WHAT ITS WORTH!!) when
Superman moves the moon over the sun to neutralise Nuclear man's powers
and he rescues Lacy and takes her back to Earth and later takes Nuclear
man and deposists him in an nuclear power plant. And last of all there
is Superman's last scene where (SPOILER AGAIN!!!) he addresses the
people of Earth and says "
And there will be peace. There will be peace when the people of the
world, want it so badly, that their governments will have no choice but
to give it to them". Great speech, Supe!!
Gene Hackman next gives a rather average performance by his high
standards but again it boils down to his character of Lex Luthor being
given virtually nothing to work with and he doesn't even have much in
the way of memorable dialogue either.
Hackman however still has some
amusing moments such as the scene Luthor breaks into the museum exhibit
of Supeman's hair holding a 1000lb weight and he does with great ease
and just uses a hedge clipper to cut it! Then there is the scene where
Luthor insults his nephew by speaking of Nuclear man's weakness of
relying on solar energy to function "He gets his energy from the sun.
Without it, he's like you at night - useless!". And lastly there is the
scene where Luthor introduces Superman to Nuclear man and he drinks a
toast to him "To a nice a guy, who is about to finish last!".
Margot Kidder also is given a pretty rough deal here in terms of role as
she (like everyone else really!) isn't given much to work with here and
as such she delivers a pretty unnatural feeling performance as Lois
Lane. However Margot still has the odd nice moment such as the scene
where Lois takes a flight with Superman and afterward Superman says to
her how sometimes he doesn't know what to do and Lois reassures "You'll
figure it out, you always do". And then there is the scene where
Superman addresses the United nations and Lacy who is with her says "I
wonder what he'll say" and Lois says (rather cheesily!) "Something
wonderful!".
Jon Cryer however is a weak link in the cast as he is for the most part
quite annoying in his role as Lenny Luthor, Lex's nephew who breaks Lex
out of jail. Cryer doesn't really have any good scenes as such although
he does get the odd cheesily amusing line such as the scene where Lex
having stolen Superman's hair "You know what I can do with a single
strand of Superman's hair?" and Lenny replies "You can make a toupee
that flies!". Yeah pretty crappy but still vaguely amusing. Mariel
Hemingway actually on the other hand does do fairly well in her role as
Lacy, who fancies Clark Kent and later is very briefly taken hostage by
Nuclear man who takes a fancy to her but she also doesn't have much in
the way of salvagable dialogue.
As for the Superman regulars, Mark McClure is largely sidelined as Jimmy
Olsen, the Daily planet photographer and given nothing to work with
here at all which is a shame given that McClure has always been a solid
performer in the series. The same also goes for Jackie Cooper who is
for the most part replaced in the film by Sam Wanamaker who himself
fails to make any kind of decent impression here in the film. And its a
pity in a way that they bothered to include the character of David
Warfield and not just keep Perry White as the editor of the DP.
Its also kind of worth noting that the film actually even features an
early performance from Jim Broadbent as a goon who briefly works for
Luthor and there is also even a performance William Hootkins (who was
also in Star Wars and Batman, bit of a comedown then here!). However
neither as these performances makes much of an impression not that they were able to.
And last of all there is Mark Pillow as Nuclear man and well... what can
you say about him???? It has to be said that Pillow is easily the
weakest actor in the film and his villain is entirely forgettable and
somewhat useless (but more on that soon!). And Pillow's actual voice
(as far as I know) isn't even used as Gene Hackman does the voice for
Pillow so that makes you wonder was Pillow such as naff actor he needed a
great one to voice him??? Whatever the case might have been it doesn't
change that Pillow fails to make any kind of impact with his
performance (such as it is).
And what is actually quite ironic is that the deleted scenes from the
film actually include an alternate version of Nuclear man (played
pricelessly by Clive Mantle) in which N-man is just a basic imbecile who
is grown at Luthor's place and is created with a pot pan over his
genitals! And later we see Nuclear man go to a nightclub and afterward
confront Superman in a back alley. And these scenes themselves are
nothing short of hilarious and they may even have been an improvement on
Pillow's nuclear man for all we know! It might have made the film even
less serious to take than it already wasn't but it would have made for a
good laugh!
DIRECTOR AND MUSIC
As for the film's director, Sidney J. Furie.... well, well, well poor
guy, that is all I can say! Furie, who actually once directed solid,
credible films such as The Ipcress File has been reduced here to this as
he has morely mis-directed the film than directed it! Furie however
might not be entirely at fault as he had to deal with such obstacles as
budget restrictions and also the film's producers, Golan and Golbus who
actually had even refused to let Furie shoot the United Nations scene in
New York and instead he had to film it in a car park in Milton Keynes!
So Furie's efforts most likely were nullified by his producers and
ultimaltey and rather unfortunately he was forced to direct the film
with one hand tied behind his back, which is a pity because with a
bigger budget and better producers who knows???
As for the music well the score was written by Alexander Courage, who of
course still utilised John William's themes which remain one of the
better things about the film although Courage's own contributions are
nothing special however they aren't horribly offensive either to the
film. So for the most part Courage doesn't do any big disservice to the
franchise and his score remains one of the film's more modestly
respectable aspects.
FLAWS
As for flaws.....can Superman IV possibly have any???? Hmmmmmmmmmm. Yeahhh! Yes it can. So this might be quite a big section.
OK well yep it has its flaws and for starters one of the main flaws of
the film comes down to the fact that it simply does not have a good
story and the story itself is not cohesive and it doesn't make a whole
lot of sense either! The film also as I previously said has an
unnatural and unrealistic feeling to it that even the previous Superman
films sort of had (well the first one did anyway!) but here the series
has become an awful parody of itself and you can no longer really take
it or any the characters seriously. The film is also riddled with plot
holes but I will get to some of them in a bit.
Another big problem with the film also comes from its fairly modest
budget (17 million dollars, which is more than I thought!) and the film's less than convincing special effects (supervised by John Evans) as they keep
using some obvious and awful looking green screen for Superman's flying
scenes (and even Nuclear man's for that matter). And in the first three
films you really could believe a man could fly but here you just can't
as the effects are so cheap looking and obvious! And another perfect
example of the naffness of the effects comes in the scene where Superman
rebuilds the great wall of China with his X-ray vision after Nuclear
destroys part of it but from the comic books Superman had no such power
at all!
Then there is Nuclear himself who remains one of the dumbest and most
boring of supervillains who makes no impression whatsoever on the film
or on the franchise. And as a villain he doesn't make much sense either
because as soon as he is born he is ready to disobey his creator in Lex
Luthor and later on he develops a crush on Lacy but its not even
remotely obvious that is at first the case as he just appears to look at
her picture in the paper and that's it! And before we know it Nuclear
man is intent on creating mass destruction if he doesn't get introduced
to Lacy by Superman! So at the end of it all Nuclear man isn't after
world domination, nope instead he is after a date! Although it has to
be said that Lacy might not survive Nuclear man if he goes nuclear (sorry!).
And another gaping plot hole comes from Superman's decision to rid the
planet of all nuclear weapons. Yeah OK great plan and a great gesture
to humankind.....but are we supposed to believe that while the
superpowers (no pun intended!) of the USA and the Soviet Union are
supposed to be on the brink of nuclear war against each other, are they
suddenly and willingly going to give up their nuclear weapons without a
hint of protest??!! It just seems a tad stupid to think that these
governments will instantly give up their nuclear deterrents just because
Superman says so! But in the film they do just that and before we know
we see Superman hurl all the nuclear weapons of the world into the sun!
And despite Superman's best efforts even he at the end of the film
decides that he was only partly successful in banishing the nuclear
weapons but again this is never really clearly explained as to why he
wasn't fully successful he just announces in his speech the people of
the world will have peace when they wanted bad enough! So in effect his
campaign to rid the planet of all nuclear weapons ultimately fails and
its a pretty half-assed subplot anyway since after the two scenes of
Superman throwing nuclear weapons into the sun that's the last we hear
of it!
I also have to say the amount of nuclear weapons we see captured in a large net are a pretty modest amount and surely there were WAY more nukes on Earth than the ones that Supe captured and catapulted into the sun! So, yeah, I don't quite buy that was supposed to be ALL the nuclear weapons in the world!
It also has to be said that the characters of David Warfield and Lucy
Warfield are for the most part are pointless as well to the film as all
they do (or David does) is try and bring down the Daily planet by
printing any old rubbish thinking that this will increase the paper's
circulation when it probably will have the opposite effect! Lucy
perhaps isn't quite as pointless however as she does at least serve as a
romantic subplot for Clark and then she quickly becomes the object of
Nuclear man's affections (well for about five minutes anyway!) but you
get the feeling the film certainly didn't need these characters. The
same also goes for Lenny Luthor, Lex's nephew who breaks him out of jail
but his character is just an annoying knob and offers nothing
interesting to the film.
Then we get to yet another ridiculous flaw in the film which is the
scene where Nuclear man kidnaps Lacy and flies her to the moon to finish
off his battle with Superman, yet somehow Lacy IS ABLE TO BREATH IN
OUTER SPACE!!! Yep that's right, the director and writers of this film
decided to defy any kind of logic and any common sense regarding basic
scientific principles and have this woman be able to breath freely
without a spacesuit or any other apparutus that could aid this! Well it
does again show just how well put together and thought out the story
is! Ahem!! However to be fair to the movie in actuality it is possible
for a human being to breathe in the hard vaccum of space unprotected
but albeit only for a very short amount of time.
And last of all it has to be said that on more than one occassion that
Clark Kent is spotted without his glasses on in the film, which
basically means his identity will be blown to anyone who eyeballs him!
This is especially noticeable in the scene where Lacy at the gym takes
off Clark's glasses briefly and he quickly insists he put them back on
but at that moment its a bit surprising that Lacy suddenly doesn't say
"Wow you look alot like Superman!".
And lastly of all further to this point then there is of course the daft
scene where Clark takes a walk off his apartment building roof along
with Lois and he changes into Superman and catches her and he is still
wearing his glasses and Lois quickly takes them and sticks them over the
built-in belt on her dress! And given all the flying they do its
amazing that these glasses never fall off Lois's dress into the nether
leaving Clark boned without his glasses! But nope she manages to hold
onto them and gives them back to Superman safe and sound (or he takes
them after he uses his convenient memory erasing kiss on her!).
Anyway that's it for the flaws.
SUM UP
So to sum up Superman IV: The Quest for Peace is a below average film for the most part, its poorly written and directed, the acting is pretty mediocre
and the special effects are simply crap and the film is devoid of any
interesting supporting characters or anything resembling a proper plot.
Yet miraculously somehow it manages to be oddly enjoyable and Reeve
just about does what he can to make his performance likeable enough and
at least he does provide the film with its a very few weighty and
dramatic moments.
And just maybe the film could have been something better if it had a
bigger budget and better backing from its producers (or indeed better
producers!) not to mention a better script and story. And if you are in
the right mood Superman IV is even possibly a film you might enjoy and
could file under the "its so bad its good" category. But ultimately it
is considered the worst film of the franchise with good reason as it is a
pretty naff movie overall.
So, I will rate Superman IV:
5.5 out of 10
So, that's it for now and I'll be back with another review soon.
Until then its bye for now!



