The Dark Knight Review (Revisited) "I'm not wearing hockey pads!"

Well, as I recently had been watching the Dark Knight Trilogy on Blu-ray again (4K Blu-ray this time!) I thought I would take another look at my review for the middle film of the trilogy, The Dark Knight and give it another lick of paint. I also noticed it didn't have any paragraph headings either, so figured it would be a good post to update!

So, after 12 years (its been that long?!) how does The Dark Knight fair???  Well, let's take another look and find out...

And the usual warning is coming up....

PLOT SPOILERS AHEAD!!

STORY

So a bit about the story as it all begins with the Joker (Heath Ledger) and some masked men carry out a bank robbery, where all the accomplices kill one another one by one in sequence, which was masterminded by the Joker, who escapes the bank with the money alone. 

Meanwhile Batman/Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) along with Lt Jim Gordon (Gary Oldman) decide to join forces with the D.A. Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart) in an effort to try and take down the mob.  Bruce decides to hold a fundraiser for Dent as he is impressed by his ideals, although Dent is dating Bruce's close friend and effective childhood sweetheart, Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal). 

In the meantime, the mob bosses hold a video conference with a Chinese accountant named Lau (Chin Han) who has fled to Hong Kong with the mob's money, where he promises it will be secured from the police and Dent.  The Joker however then interrupts the meeting and offers to kill Batman for half of the mob's money, but they quickly decline his offer, but the Joker insists that Lau will squeal to Batman, who doesn't believe in jurisdiction. 

The mob boss, Gambol (Michael Jai White) then puts a bounty out on the Joker's life, but the Joker who is soon captured by Gambol's men, tricks him and ends up killing Gambol and taking control of his men.  Batman then manages to travel to Hong Kong where he captures Lau and brings him back to Gotham where he agrees to testify.

Meanwhile the Joker steps up his presence in the city as he announces publicly that he will kill one person a day until Batman reveals his true identity to the press.  This prompts the Joker to kill commissioner Loeb (Colin McFarlane) as well as the judge that presides over the mob trials.  The Joker then goes after Dent at Bruce's fundraiser for him, but Bruce incapacitates and hides Dent before the Joker can get to him.  The Joker next targets Gotham's mayor but Gordon saves the mayor by taking the bullet and apparently sacrificing himself. 

Dent then in an effort to conceal Bruce's identity, announces to the press that he is Batman and he is taken into custody and pursued by the Joker and his men across the city.  The Joker in an effort to try and capture Dent is foiled by Batman and also Gordon who reveals that he faked his own death.  The Joker is then interrogated by Batman back at the police station who reveals that he has had both Rachel and Dent captured and held in two different locations in the city, where they are tied up and surrounded by explosions.

Batman and Gordon race off to the two separate locations only to find that they have been tricked and given the opposite address, as Batman arrives to rescue Rachel only to find Dent which he rescues just before the building explodes, however Rachel is as a result killed in the other explosion. 

And from this point on the Joker escalates his threats and terror on Gotham, leaving Batman to try and find a way to stop the demented murderer from wreaking widespread havoc on the city...

THOUGHTS

Although this may strange I would have to say that The Dark Knight is my least favourite of the three Nolan/Bale Batman films, yet that is saying something as it is still a very intense, dark, brooding and entertaining film.  The film also expands on the criminal elements of Gotham as we know see the mob incorporated into the story and with the Joker we get a truly terrifying and perversely amusing villain who will go to any length he sees fit to wreak the havoc he so wants on the city of Gotham.  Harvey Dent is also effectively introduced as an idealist district attorney who wants to rid the city of the mob and also just happens to be dating Bruce's close friend, Rachel Dawes, which causes some feelings of jealousy for Bruce despite impressed by Dent's own ideals.  But towards the end of the film we see the terrible fate that Dent endures at the hands of the Joker who pushes his buttons to become a criminal himself.

PERFORMANCES AND NOTABLE SCENES (Warning: this section will contain spoilers!)

Performance wise The Dark Knight is excellent all round with a very strong cast on top form.

Starting with Christian Bale who once again excels at playing Bruce Wayne as a suave, soft spoken billionaire businessman, but also happens to be the protector of Gotham at night.  However it has to be said that I was never very keen on Bale's take on Batman as its here where he decides to overdo Batman's ridiculously raspy voice in order to conceal Bruce's identity, but in practice it just sounds ridiculous!  And that remains the one big flaw in Bale's potrayal of the character because that aside he is excellent in the part as he also handles the physical action confidently. 

Bale has quite a few highlights in the film and some good lines of dialoge even, such as the first scene where Batman appears who apprehends the criminal Doctor Crane AKA Scarecrow (Cillian Murphy again) carrying out an illegal deal only to be intercepted by fake Batmen dressed in poor batsuits and Batman ties them all up.  And in the scene, Batman looks to Scarecrow and tells him "Don't let me find you out here again!" and the fake Batman says "We just want to help" and Batman walks off and says "I don't need help!" and Scarecrow weighs in and says "Not my diagnosis!".  But then the fake Batmen asks "What gives you the right?! What is the difference between you and me?" and Batman says as he gets into his bat mobile "I'm not wearing hockey pads!". 

Another good scene is where Batman brutally interrogates the Joker at the police station and the Joker says is he prepared to break his one rule (i.e. not to kill) and Batman says "I'm considering it!" and proceeds to beat the Joker until he tells him where he has Rachel and Dent held captive. 

Then there is the scene near the end where Batman tries to find the Joker and ends up fighting with him, as the Joker holds Batman near the edge of a smashed window in a high story building, he says "If we don't stop fighting, we're gonna miss the fireworks!". So, as the time strikes midnight, he awaits one of the boats he has rigged to blow up but it doesn't happen. And Batman asks Joker "What were you trying to prove? That deep down people are just as ugly as you?!" and the Joker annoyed says "Can't rely one anyone these days!" and he takes out another remote from his jacket and he says"Don't worry, I came prepared! By the way do you wanna know how I got these scars???" and Batman says "No, but I know how you got these!" and fires his suit's gauntlet blades into the Joker's face chest..

And then there is the scene near the end where Batman confronts the scarred Dent, who is now nicknamed himself as "two face" and Batman tries to stop Dent from killing Gordon's family and Dent angrily says "The Joker chose to save ME!" and Batman says "Because you were the best of us!  He wanted to prove that some one even as good as you can fall!".

WARNING BIG SPOILER COMING UP!!

So, in the final scene of the film, Batman manages to stop Dent from killing Gordon's family but Dent falls to his death as a result. So, Batman takes it upon himself to take the fall for Dent's death and he says to Gordon "You either die a hero, or live long enough to become the villain" and he says to Gordon "Call it in. I killed those people. Call it in. I can take the fall for Dent". However, Dent refuses to and says "You can't! You're not! You..." and Batman says "I'm whatever Gotham needs me to be". Dent then warns Batman "They'll hunt you" and Batman realises and says "You'll hunt me, set the dogs on me, because its what needs to happen. Because sometimes the truth isn't good enough and people deserve more...".

And then there is Heath Ledger, who without question, provides the film's best performance as he is simply superb in his role as the film's main villain the psychotic Joker and he plays with him with a creepy sense of malice, twisted humour and intensity. Ledger himself died before the film was released from a drug overdose in January 2008 and the film was partly dedicated in his memory. Ledger also went to win a posthumous oscar for best supporting actor. 

Ledger has many highlights in the film right from his first scene where he robs the bank at the start of the film and after he has scheme to kill all of his accomplices, he shoots the bank manager in the stomach (William Fitchner) who out of disgust asks "What do you believe in, huh?!  WHAT DO YOU BELIEVE IN?!".  And the Joker walks up to him and jams what appears to be a grenade in the bank manager's mouth and says "I believe that whatever doesn't kill you, simply makes you.....stranger!" and he pulls of his mask to reveal his white painted face and scarred lips and red make-up on his mouth. 

Then there is the scene the Joker walks in on the mob who are having a video conference call with the Chinese accountant, Lau, who talks of his plan to keep the mob's money safe and the Joker says "And I thought my jokes were bad!".  And in the scene there is a funny moment where the Joker sticks a pencil down on the table and he says "I'm gonna make this pencil disappear!" and one of the mob bosses men walks over to attack him and the Joker slams the man's head onto the pencil, killing him, the Joker says "Ta da!  Its gone!". 

Another great scene is where the Joker gatecrashes Bruce's fundraiser for Dent and he grabs Rachel and holds a knife close to her face and tells her how he got his scars.  And he tells her of the story (most likely a lie) of how his former wife got her faced cut up after owing money to loan sharks and he says "She can't take it.  I just want to see her smile again!  I just want her to know I don't care about the scars.  So I do this and stick a razor in my mouth and do this... to myself.  And you know what?  She can't stand the sight of me!  She leaves.  Now I side the funny side.  Now I'm always smiling!" and she pushes him away and he says "A little fight in you!  I like that!".  And the Joker does the same to the mob boss Gambol, although he tells a different story about his father sticking the knife in his mouth and says "Why so serious, son?!  Let's put a smile on that face!".   

Another chilling moment is where the Joker captures a police officer and records him on video and asks him "So Brian, do you think Batman has made Gotham a better place??  Look at me" and the officer shies away too scared and the Joker explodes with a demonic response "LOOK AT ME!!!". So, Joker turns the camera to face himself and he says " You see? This is how crazy Batman's made Gotham! You want order in Gotham? Batman must take off his mask and turn himself in. Oh, and every day he doesn't, people will die. Starting tonight. I'm a man of my word!" and he laughs maniacally into the camera before shutting it off.

Then there is the scene where Batman interrogates the Joker at the police station and Batman appears silently behind him and he slams the Joker's against the table and the Joker says "Never start with the head.  The victim get's all fuzzy.  He can't feel the next...." and Batman cuts him off by punching the Joker's hand and the Joker whinces and says "See?!".  And in the scene Batman asks the Joker "Why do you wan't to kill me??" and the Joker laughs hysterically and says "I don't wanna kill you?  Why I would kill you???  What would I do without you???  You COMPLETE me!!". 

Another good scene is when the Joker (dressed as a nurse no less!) enters the hospital where Dent is being treated and he gives him the opportunity to kill him as he gives Dent a gun and let's him point it at his head.  And the Joker says "I'm an agent of chaos.  Oh, and you know the thing about chaos is?  Its fair!" and Dent holds a coin up showing heads and tails and he says "You live" showing him the good side, then the scarred side "You die" and the Joker grins saying "Now we're talking!".  And in the next scene we see that the Joker has survived the coin toss and he leaves the building and having rigged the hospital with explosives he triggers the detonator, which only partially works, then he presses it again and the whole hospital goes up!

Aaron Eckhart is also excellent in his role as Harvey Dent (and later Two-Face) as the ambitious and seemingly incorruptible D.A. who is out to target the mob and rid Gotham of its criminals.

Eckhart has a good opening scene in court where he questions one of the mob's associates who belongs to the mob boss Maroni (Eric Roberts) on the stand.  And the mobster tries to kill Dent, who grabs the gun and punches him and takes it away and he says "Made in China.  If you want to kill a public servant, Mr Maroni, I suggest you buy American!" and as the Judge tells the bailiffs to take away the mob guy, Dent says "But you're honor, I'm not done!". 

And later on when Gordon vists Dent in the hospital, after Dent has been badly scarred down half his face, Dent insists Gordon to tell him what his nickname used to be "Remember the name you all had for me when I was at internal affairs?  What was it?" and Gordon is reluctant which prompts Dent to yell "SAY IT!!!" and Gordon quietly says "Two-face.  Harvey Two-Face".  And Gordon after says "I'm sorry, Harvey, I truly am" and Dent shows the other side of his scarred face and he says "No you're not.  Not yet!".

Then there is the scene where Dent confronts Maroni in his car about who let the Joker out of prison and Maroni says to blame it on the Joker and Dent says "The Joker is a mad dog, I want to know who let him off the leash?". So, Maroni asks Dent "If I tell you, will you let me go?" and Dent says "It can't hurt your chances" and Maroni tells him "It was Ramirez". So, Dent then pulls out his gun and coin and Maroni panics and says "But you said..." and Dent interrupts him and says "I said it couldn't hurt your chances..." and he flips the coin and he looks at it and tells Maroni "You're a lucky a man" and Maroni smiles a little. However, Dent flips the coin again and he tells Dent "But he's not" and Maroni asks "Who?" and Dent tells him "You're driver" and he buckles up his belt and shoots the driver in the back, causing the car to crash and topple over.  

Which brings me onto Gary Oldman, who also provides a fine performance as Jim Gordon, who eventually is promoted from Lieutenant to Commissioner after Loeb is killed after he has been poisoned by the Joker. 

Oldman also has some good scenes such as the one where he questions the Joker at the station, getting nowhere Gordon changes tack and uncuffs the Joker and says "If we are gonna play games.... I'm gonna need a coffee" and he starts to leave the room.  And the Joker says "Ah the old good cop, bad cop routine??" and Gordon says "not exactly" and leaves the room and the lights turn on in the room to reveal Batman stands right behind the Joker. 

And there is also the scene where Bruce Wayne saves one of the Joker's targets by crashing his car into a van that would have collided with the target's car.  And as the Joker has rigged the city's central hospital, Bruce says after the crash "You think I should go to the hospital?" and Gordon says "You don't watch a whole lot of news do you, Mr Wayne?!". 

And in the film's last scene (PLOT SPOILER) where Gordon tells his son after Batman has saved Gordon's family and asks that Gordon pin Dent's death on him, Batman does a runner.  And Gordon's son asks why Batman is running and Gordon says "Because we have to chase him.  He's the hero Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now.  So we'll hunt him.  So he can take it.  Because he's not our silent hero.  He's a silent guardian.  A watchful protector.  A dark knight". 

Maggie Gyllenhaal is also an excellent replacement to Katie Holmes as Rachel Dawes and she plays the part with a bit more sass and maturity than Holmes did. 

Gyllenhaal has some good scene that include her first where Rachel walks out of court with Dent at the beginning of the film just after a mobster tries to shoot him in the courtroom. So Rachel says to Dent "We'll never link Maroni to the gun, so we can't charge him, but the fact that they tried to kill you means we're getting to them". Dent then says to Rachel "Glad you're so pleased, Rachel. I'm fine by the way!" and Rachel says "Come on, Harvey, if you aren't getting shot at in this town, your not doing your job right!". Rachel then says to Dent "Of course, if you are rattled we could take the rest of the day off..." and Dent tells her "I can't. I've dragged the head of the major crimes unit down here" and Rachel asks "Jim Gordon? He's a friend - try to be nice!".

And lastly there is the scene at Bruce's fundraiser event for Dent, he gives a speech to Dent, praising him for putting the mobsters in jail. However, Rachel is not so impressed as she goes out onto a balcony where Bruce stands pondering things. And Rachel, angrily says to Bruce "Harvey may not understand you well enough to know when you are making fun of him. But I do!". Bruce however tells her "No, I meant every word. The day you told me about, Gotham no longer needing Batman, its coming" and Rachel looks concerned and says "You can't ask me to wait for that".

Michael Caine is also in fine form again as Bruce Wayne's butler, Alfred Pennyworth and he has some good moments in the film as well and he proves the film with some levity to lighten its pretty dark tone. 

Caine also provides the film with a good speech as Bruce in his Bat quarters (as at this point Wayne manor must be still being repaired after it was burned down in Batman Begins) looks at the video of the Joker and says "Criminals aren't complicated, Alfred, I just need to figure what he's after".  And Alfred says "Perhaps with respect, Mr Wayne, this is a man you don't fully understand either.  Because some men aren't looking for anything logical, like money.  They can't be bought, bullied, reasoned or negotiated with.  Some men just want to watch the world burn!". 

There is also the scene where at Dent's fundraiser, where Dent asks Alfred about Rachel and he says to Alfred "Rachel says she's you known all of her life" and he smiles and says "Not yet, sir" and Dent quietly asks "Any psychotic ex-boyfriends I should know about?" and Alfred smiles saying "Oh you have no idea!". 

Then there is the scene where Bruce and Alfred arrange to cancel the Russian ballerinas show in Gotham and has them all taken on a large yacht as a diversion for him to travel out of the city.  And in the scene Bruce asks "You'll be all right, Alfred without me?" and he dives into the water to get to a small plane to take him out to Hong Kong, Alfred quietly says "You can tell me Russian for "You apply your own bloody sun-tan lotion!".  

And last of all Morgan Freeman who is reliable in anything he does, makes a good retun as Lucius Fox, the CEO of Wayne Enterprises who acts as Bruce's armourer for his nocturnal activities as Batman. 

Freeman has some good scenes as well and the first one that springs to mind comes when a weasly accountant, Reese tries to blackmail Lucius into giving him money to keep quiet about the fact that he has found blueprints for Batman's car and devices.  And Lucius calmly replies "Let me get this straight.  You think that your client, one of the wealthiest and most powerful men in the world, is secretly a vigilante, who spends his nights beating criminals to a pulp with his bear hands.  And your plan is to blackmail this person???  Good luck!".    

Another good scene is where Fox shows Bruce some new gadgets he can try out in his effort to capture Lau who has travelled to Hong Kong and has the mob's money and he intends to use a plane to do it.

So, in the scene, Bruce asks Fox "How about getting back into the plane?" and Fox says sarcily "I can recommend a good travel agent" and Bruce adds "Without it landing" and Fox smiles and says "That's more like it, Mr Wayne!". Fox then shows Bruce a new batsuit, which is lighter in design and Bruce asks "How will it hold up against dogs?" (as he was attacked by a dog at the start of the film) and Fox asks "You talking chihuahuas or rotweilers?" and Bruce smiles and Fox with a smile says "It should do fine against cats!". 

And last of all is the scene where Batman uses Fox's sonar device to track every mobile phone in the city in an effort to find the Joker, much to Fox's displeasure.

So, in the scene Fox looks at big bank of screens with the sonar imaging on it and he says to Batman "You took my sonar concept and applied it to everybody's phone in the City.  With half the city feeding you sonar you can image all of Gotham. This is wrong!". Batman then says "I have to find thus man, Lucius" and Fox asks "But at what cost?" and Batman says "The database is null key encrypted. Only one person can access it" and Fox says "No one should have that kind of power" and Batman says "That's why I gave it to you. Only you can use it". Fox then says "I will help you this one time. But consider this my resignation. As long as this machine is at Wayne industries, I won't be!".

DIRECTOR AND MUSIC

As for the film's director, Christopher Nolan yet again does a great job and he handles the film's action scenes confidently and builds up the tension and suspense really well throughout the film's lengthy running time.  Nolan also provides a pretty dark tone for the film like he did with Batman Begins but he does allow for some moments of humour here and there just to keep it from being overwhelmingly serious and dour.  Nolan also makes good use of IMAX cameras during the film's action scenes, particularly during the opening bank robbery and also when the Joker attacks the police van that holds Dent.

And last of all Hans Zimmer and James Newton Howard work together again to provide another fine music score for the film, which doesn't quite scale the heights of Zimmer's score for The Dark Knight Rises, but its still good enough and has plenty of tense and atmospheric moments to it. There are times however where its mix of pounding drums and strings are a bit overkill but that aside its still a fine score for the most part.

FLAWS (Warning: this section may contain spoilers!)

So as for flaws.....we'll The Dark Knight for me as I said remains the weakest of the three films but that's not to say it is a really good film, which it certainly is, but one of the flaws of the film is it length as at just over two and a half hours, its just a bit too long and drawn out and certain scenes kind of slow things down a bit.  This is evident in such scenes as where the Joker kills off people in the wake of Batman revealing his identity and Gordon faking his own death and eventually comes back to his family. 

Another issue I had is with Harvey Dent as Two-Face when you look at his facial scares, half of his face is badly scarred and we see his flesh and bone sticking out aswell as his eyelid has been burnt away, yet somehow he is still talking normaly!!  I mean wouldn't his speech be severely impaired in reality if he were to suffers scars like that???  Yet he walks around with no ill effects and can talk fluently with no lisps or slurs and it just seems a bit improbable that would be the case not to mention he would need some mighty strong painkillers! But then again as I've said before it is a Hollywood film so you just have to suspend all belief. 

I also felt that the ending in a way was a bit stupid that Batman decides to take the fall for Dent in order to protect his public image after his death, as everyone would surely know that its not in Batman's character to even kill someone anyway and he even says that himself its the one rule he doesn't break. Why not basically pin it on the Joker, who was behind Dent's downfall in the first place?! That would seem to be a more sensible suggestion than a completely out of character decision on Batman's behalf, who has always had a "no kill" policy.

And lastly, I find it a bit bizarre just how well connected the Joker is in how that he managed to somehow place a bomb on both boats containing evacuees from the city. I mean he has his share of men I guess but it still seems improbable that they can be everywhere at any time. However again it is a film, so you'll just have to suspend disbelief once more!

SUM UP

So, to sum after 12 years, The Dark Knight is still an excellent film even if it is a bit overlong and in my own humle opinion, the weakest of the trilogy and a bit overrated in my opinion but all that said it still holds up really well. And its performances, action scenes and plotlines are all very well handled for the most part and it certainly remains a film to rewatch. 

So, that's it for now and I will be back hopefully before the end of the month with another post.

Till then its bye the now!